'Serious problems' with vote that kept Vladimir Putin in power, monitors say

Vladimir Putin easily wins a third-term presidency despite massive street protests and allegations of fraud. NBC's Jim Maceda reports. 

Updated at 11:40 a.m. ET: MOSCOW -- Russia's presidential election was clearly skewed in favor of Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, international vote monitors said in a report on Monday.

"There was no real competition and abuse of government resources ensured that the ultimate winner of the election was never in doubt," Tonino Picula, one of the vote monitors from the Organization for Security and Co-Operation in Europe, said in a statement.

Monitors cited "serious problems" with the vote and called for alleged electoral violations in Sunday's election to be thoroughly investigated.


Golos, Russia's leading independent elections watchdog, earlier said it had registered at least 3,100 reports of violations nationwide.

Golos cited received numerous reports of "carousel voting," in which busloads of voters are driven around to cast ballots multiple times.

The Central Elections Commission said Putin got more than 63 percent of the nationwide vote. However, Golos said that incomplete reports from its observers of individual polling station counts indicate Putin hovered perilously close to the 50-percent mark needed for a first-round victory.

Accounts of extensive vote-rigging looked set to strengthen the resolve of opposition forces whose unprecedented protests in recent months have posed the first serious challenge to Putin's heavy-handed rule.

Anti-Putin activists pay high price

Putin said the presidential election had prevented Russia from falling into the hands of enemies. Complaining of widespread fraud, his opponents said they would rally near the Kremlin on Monday night.

His eyes brimming with tears, the former KGB spy defiantly proclaimed to a sea of supporters that they had triumphed over opponents intent on "destroying Russia's statehood and usurping power."

Putin's win was never in doubt as many across the vast country still see him as a guarantor of stability and the defender of a strong Russia against a hostile world, an image he has carefully cultivated during 12 years in power.

'Honest struggle'
Putin claimed victory Sunday night when fewer than a quarter of the votes had been counted. He spoke to a rally just outside the Kremlin walls of tens of thousands of supporters, many of them government workers or employees of state-owned companies who had been ordered to attend.

"I promised that we would win and we have won!" Putin shouted to the flag-waving crowd. "We have won in an open and honest struggle."

He ended his speech with the triumphant declaration: "Glory to Russia!"

Putin was president from 2000 until 2008, before moving into the prime minister's office due to term limits.

Putin, 59, is on collision course with the mainly middle-class protesters who have staged rallies in the capital and other big cities since since December.

Corruption
The wave of protests began after a parliamentary election in which observers produced evidence of widespread vote fraud. Protest rallies in Moscow drew tens of thousands in the largest outburst of public anger in post-Soviet Russia, demonstrating growing exasperation with the pervasive corruption and tight controls over political life under Putin.

The protest organizers, who see Putin as an autocratic leader whose return to power will stymie hope of economic and political reforms, said their demonstrations would now grow.

Russia's presidential election takes place on Sunday, Mar. 4. Rock Center Correspondent Harry Smith journeyed to Moscow where he met blogger Alexei Navalny, a vocal opponent of Vladimir Putin and his party United Russia. Navalny has galvanized protesters through social media and uses his website to expose alleged political corruption. The prospect of Putin returning to the presidency has generated protests in Russia not seen since the fall of Communism. The surging public outrage has left some wondering if a movement is afoot in Russia similar to that of last year's Arab Spring. 

"He is forcing things to breaking point. He is declaring war on us. As a result the base of aversion to him is growing," said journalist Sergei Parkhomenko, one of the leaders of the opposition protest movement.

"These elections are not free. ... That's why we'll have protests (Monday)," said Mikhail Kasyanov, who was Putin's first prime minister before going into opposition. "We will not recognize the president as legitimate."

Putin's campaign chief, Stanislav Govorukhin, rejected the claims of violations, calling them "ridiculous."

Putin in power until 2024? 10 key questions about the Russian election

Partial results, with nearly 100 percent of the votes counted, put Putin on almost 64 percent of the votes.

His nearest rival, Communist Party leader Gennady Zyuganov, was on about 17 percent of votes, and nationalist Vladimir Zhirinovsky, former parliamentary speaker Sergei Mironov and billionaire Mikhail Prokhorov were below 10 percent.

Ivan Sekretarev / AP

Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, who claimed victory in Sunday's presidential election, gets emotional during a rally in Moscow on Sunday.

Prokhorov, the owner of the NBA's New Jersey Nets, won plaudits for his campaign. He said on Channel One television after the vote that his observers had been kept away from some polling stations and were beaten on two occasions.

Zyuganov said his party would not recognize the result and called the election "illegitimate, dishonest and not transparent".

Despite the opposition, mainly among well-educated and relatively well-off young professionals, Putin's support remains high in the provinces and his victory had not been in doubt.

Putin got more than 90 percent of the vote in several Caucasus provinces, including 99.8 percent in Chechnya.

Television presenter and journalist Tina Kandelaki, a Kremlin supporter who nonetheless found her Unreal Politics discssion programme censored last year, was among a panel appointed by Putin to monitor election fraud.

She told msnbc.com on Monday: "Every complaint will be considered separately and we will do our best to punish law-breakers. All those cases are being checked now. If these complaints are confirmed, we’ll submit cases to the court."

However, she claimed a complaint that 300 buses carrying voters from the province of Dagestan to the central Moscow was examined and "after checking it wasn't confirmed".

Asked about the longer-term implications of Putin's victory, she said: "I'm pretty sure that there would be some political concessions...and the situation with the opposition would change as well." She also believes the process of registration for political parties would be "simplified".

Economic boom
The initial challenge for the man credited by many Russians with rebuilding the country's image and overseeing an economic boom in his first presidency, had been to win more than half the votes on Sunday and avoid a second-round runoff.

His clear victory will enable him to portray his return to the presidency as a strong sign of public support against the protesters, whom he has portrayed as a destabilizing minority and pawns of foreign governments.

But the mood has shifted in the country of 143 million and the urban protest movement portrays him as an obstacle to change and the guardian of a corrupt system of power.

Putin, who will be inaugurated in May, is likely to revert to the fighting talk against the West that was the hallmark of his first presidency and his election campaign.

The West can expect Putin to continue the tough policies he has pursued even as prime minister, including opposing U.S. plans to build a missile shield in Europe and resisting international military intervention in Syria.

"Putin is a brave and persistent man who can resist the U.S. and EU pressure," said Anastasia Lushnikova, a 20-year-old student who voted for Putin in the southern city of Rostov-on-Don.

The Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report.

More from msnbc.com and NBC News:

Follow us on Twitter: @msnbc_world

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 ... 4 5 6

I really couldn't care less if there are "problems" with the Russian vote. It's none of our business.

Can we just worry about the problems we have here at home for awhile?

  • 1 vote
Reply#136 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 3:59 PM EST

Putin and Obama are pretty much in agreement as far as policies as far as I can see anyway whats the Big Deal Putin seems like a typical Dem Right?

  • 1 vote
Reply#137 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 4:01 PM EST

Come on now ! Did anyone think the Russian election would be "open and honest, reflecting the will of the Russian people"? Mr. Putin hates the U.S. and will do anything to stay in power! Russia and China ride roughshod over the U.S. and we let them get away with it. We will soon be a third world country if Americans do not wake up to reality an start making major changes in our world atitude, starting with firing anyone,(democrat or republican) in the government that does not fight for, and believe in this country.

    Reply#138 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 4:01 PM EST

    Geeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee what a surprise. He must have visited Florida and picked some pointers.

      Reply#139 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 4:07 PM EST

      These countries amaze me when they pretend to have democracy. I watched on the news recently where Iran was holding open elections and I saw the president casting a ballot in a plastic box held securely closed by zip ties. What a sham. Do these morons honestly believe that we think they are performing a fair election. Makes me sick.

        Reply#140 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 4:15 PM EST

        "I watched on the news recently where Iran was holding open elections and I saw the president casting a ballot in a plastic box held securely closed by zip ties. What a sham."

        Many areas even here,you drop your ballot in a box.The box usually has a padlock on it.But the election officials have the key.So how is that much different.Its not important how to drop your vote,its important that its counted fairly.

          #140.1 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 6:23 PM EST
          Reply

          If the MSM here in the United States would give the voter/election fraud the same coverage as they are giving Russias, we might could have a fair election..but alas,thats not gonna happen as the MSM are merely puppets of the powers that be..so sad for America and shame be cast to the MSM for not being fair and balanced reporting as they all claim. For many years the people could trust the media to report out loud any breaches of the Constitution...that time has come and gone..I pray for my children and grandchildren that they will have a chance to live in a truly Free America and not the fascist state it appears to be headed for.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#141 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 4:36 PM EST

          The Left wing has most of the media except Fox and Radio and if Obama gets in again they will try to silence that with the Fairness Doctrine so they can legally dictate whats talked about and you FN Libs are going for this B.S by the time you dumbells figure out what these people are it will be too Late.....................disgusting.

            Reply#142 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 4:46 PM EST

            putin is sadly singing the same song as assad but sadly it is out of tune.

              Reply#143 - Mon Mar 5, 2012 9:11 PM EST

              ellie.....hooray for you ! While everyone seems to be pointing at the election shenanigans going on in Russia, they forget that we in th US have crooked elections as well. Here in America, dead people vote, dogs vote, voter fraud happens, redistricting, gandymandering, votes are declared invalid, petitions are falsified, voting machines malfunction, but thats ok.......it's DEMOCRACY !

              When they do these things in Iran, or Korea, or Russia....it's EVIL ! I think we should clean up our own pig-sty before we comment on how someone else keeps their house......or is it that we want to invade russia next ?

                Reply#144 - Tue Mar 6, 2012 12:36 AM EST

                Isn't this really (at this point) an internal, civil matter? The "West" and U.N. did not like the results. That is what it boils down to. Syria just had elections. The results were not even completely in and outsiders, not liking the result, were all ready on the attack. The same has been said about Egypt and will be said after Iran finishes it's voting.

                However, it is okay to raise a billion dollars (DNC) to buy the US Presidency.

                  Reply#145 - Tue Mar 6, 2012 2:43 AM EST

                  Haha, Wow. What a propaganda, Msnbc =D. VLADIMIR PUTIN! RASSIYA YEST PUTINA!

                    Reply#146 - Tue Mar 6, 2012 3:07 AM EST

                    Duh!

                      Reply#147 - Thu Mar 8, 2012 5:18 AM EST

                      Putin gave a stability to Russia. A lot of People support him. Old people got their pensions back. Young people support him, because he is their role model.

                        Reply#148 - Thu Mar 8, 2012 8:04 AM EST

                        I really couldn't care less if there are "problems" with the Russian vote. It's none of our business.

                        Can we just worry about the problems we have here at home for awhile?

                        I agree with Dr. Boogie!!! It is not our business who is elected overseas. We need to fix our own problems.

                          Reply#149 - Thu Mar 8, 2012 8:07 AM EST

                          Hooke's law. When one says Putin has erased democracy in Russia, it's worth to ask what there was before him. Democracy? Or maybe anarchy and terror? Of course there were some traces of democracy under Yeltsin when he was not mortally drunk. There was something like competitiveness in government and criminal business. And of course there were no corruption because corruption occurs only in stable, predictable society where crime and power are a little different things.

                          But what happened to Russian people during 1990s? Human rights? Intoxication with pro-American euphoria merged with total poverty and fear of unleashed criminals. Good conditions for adapting democracy! Would you like pretty kittens if one of them was depicted on the clothes of a maniac having raped you in your childhood?

                          Yes, Putin performed some reduction of democracy, but 50% of Russians ignored it as unimportant and most of others were hating this word per se. Only as wealth level and civic peace got some moderate level, people (not majority yet) began to notice something wrong with their rights, freedoms etc. However the most of these violations are caused by local authorities still bearing psychology of junior thug. Even ignoring wealth and self-conscience restored, Putin's undemocratic manners turn Russians to democracy much better than ridiculous American claims. Reductio ad absurdum. But the more USA tend to criticize Putin the less Russians tolerate american ideals, turning even not to Putin but to much more dangerous far-right opposition.

                          So thanks US government for struggling against Russian democracy! Iran's democracy is already killed, their people elect those who shouts more loudly curses against America thanks to international pressure. Excellent! Kali Yuga in its peak.

                            Reply#150 - Fri Mar 9, 2012 1:58 PM EST
                            Jump to discussion page: 1 ... 4 5 6
                            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.