Was Islamist gunman Mohamed Merah an informant for French spies?

France 2 via AP

Mohamed Merah shown in this image from French TV station France 2

Mohamed Merah, the gunman who killed seven people including three Jewish children, may have been an informant for France's intelligence services, according to reports that raise further questions about whether authorities missed chances to prevent the attacks.

The 23-year-old, who is a French citizen of Algerian origin, shot dead three Muslim soldiers as well as three children and a rabbi at a Jewish school before being slain by police commandos at the end of a 32-hour standoff in an apartment in Toulouse.


It later emerged Merah had traveled to Afghanistan and Israel in 2010 and had been interviewed in November 2011 by the domestic intelligence agency Direction Centrale du Renseignement Intérieur (DCRI).

Bernard Squarcini, head of the agency, was quoted by French newspaper Le Monde as saying Merah asked for a local DCRI agent by name while he was holed-up in the apartment surrounded by police.

Father of Toulouse gunman wants to sue France for killing son

Squarcini told Le Monde that Merah shocked the female agent by saying: "Anyway, I was going to call you to say I had some tip-offs for you, but actually I was going to [kill] you.”

Merah, who told police he had been inspired to commit his attacks by al-Qaida, used the French word "fumer", which means "to smoke," which is a slang term that also means to "murder" or "waste."

Squarcini’s remarks to Le Monde were reported in other French media, including Liberation and Le Figaro.

 

'Not trivial'
Yves Bonnet, former head of an intelligence agency that was merged with DCRI in 2008, told Toulouse newspaper La Dépêche du Midi that it was significant that Merah appeared to have a regular contact at the DCRI. “Having a contact is not totally innocent,” he told the newspaper. “This is not trivial.”

Italian newspaper Il Foglio said Merah’s trip to Israel and Afghanistan in September 2010 was made with the knowledge of the French foreign secret service, the Direction Générale de la Sécurité Extérieure. However, London's Independent newspaper quoted a spokesman for the agency as dismissing that report as "grotesque".

Squarcini has since insisted Merah was not helping authorities, telling Liberation the gunman was not "an informer for the DCRI or any other French or foreign services."

Meanwhile, Merah’s body will be flown to Algeria on Thursday if the country agrees to receive it, an official at one of the biggest mosques in Paris told Reuters.

Abdallah Zekri said Merah's body was being kept at a hospital in Toulouse while Algerian authorities decided whether they were willing to receive it. French media had reported that Merah's father had requested burial in Algeria.

On Tuesday, Merah's father, Mohamed Benalen Merah, lashed out at French authorities for killing his son. The elder Merah, who lives in Algeria, had earlier said he wanted to sue France.

"France is a powerful country with huge resources," Merah told France 24 television. "They could have taken him while he slept. They could have used a sleep-inducing gas and taken him like a baby. Why were they so hasty? Why did they kill him?"

"They could have arrested him and had him face justice," he added.

However, the BBC said French Foreign Minister Alain Juppe responded: "If I were the father of such a monster, I would shut my mouth in shame.”

More from msnbc.com and NBC News:

Follow us on Twitter: @msnbc_world

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2

"Merah's father, Mohamed Benalen Merah, lashed out at French authorities for killing his son."

France should put a hit on the scums scummy father.

  • 8 votes
Reply#1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:41 AM EDT

Do the French vet their spies?

    #1.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:56 AM EDT

    What a stretch......I often used names of the captains, the Mayors and many other public officials ...didn't mean for one second I worked for them. The punk ass killed himself as he should of done right before he thought of killing 7 others. Just another cowardly Muslim. Still waiting for someone to tell me what GOOD if any can be found by this so called peaceful religious group. Who have they helped and not killed?

    • 5 votes
    #1.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:05 AM EDT

    "On Tuesday, Merah's father, Mohamed Benalen Merah, lashed out at French authorities for killing his son. The elder Merah, who lives in Algeria, had earlier said he wanted to sue France."

    Sorry buddy! Your son is a @!$%#ing murderer! A grown man capable of living like a coward and dying by it. Hopefully you don't have any other offspring as I am sure they are just as crazy in living out their fathers' ideologies of being such devout "peaceful" Muslims.

    • 1 vote
    #1.3 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:31 AM EDT

    Does anybody else think the guy looks like Voldemort in the picture at the top of this page? The guy got shot and killed for a good reason.

    • 2 votes
    #1.4 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:59 AM EDT

    Merah told France 24 television. "They could have taken him while he slept. They could have used a sleep-inducing gas and taken him like a baby. Why were they so hasty? Why did they kill him?"

    Hasty? Hasty?! A 30 hour standoff with multiple opportunities for the gunmen to surrender is hasty?! Hate to break this to you, Mohamed, but your son is a dumbsh*t murdering psychopath and got every bit of lead that he deserved. You think they were hasty? Try that sh*t in America, bub, see what SWAT does to you and how quickly they do it.

    French Foreign Minister Alain Juppe responded: "If I were the father of such a monster, I would shut my mouth in shame.”

    Got that right. What a tool this father is-- going to sue France? How about France sues you for raising such a dysfunctional little Bin Laden wannabe? Your failure of a son killed 7 people and you're upset that he was shot and killed in return? You are an unbelievable fool if you believe that your son deserved any better. Take the French Foreign Ministers advice and just hang your head in shame.

    • 3 votes
    #1.5 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 10:09 AM EDT

    Why don't the french authorities release the CCTV of the FAT man on the scooter who shot the soldiers.

    "Mohamed Merah" One witness described the killer as "quite fat" and having a tattoo or scar on his face. (BBC News )w

    The alleged Toulouse shooter, Mohamed Merah, would appear to be an innocent patsy.

      #1.6 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 10:40 AM EDT

      "Palestinians protest the killing of Martyr Mohamed Merah. News at 11:00."

      • 1 vote
      #1.7 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:25 PM EDT

      This father will never feel shame, all his child did was kill infidels and Jews, to him and the rest of the Muslim world he should be held up as a hero. The sad thing is with this type of thinking we have the liberals, the Europeans and a all the racist hate groups screaming about Israel, but never would a Israeli be held up as a hero for doing such a terrible act, yet people hate them and want to submit to the Arabs. Until we realize that this will never stop until we bomb the whole bunch, take their oil away and turn them back into people that live in tents and ride on camels this will never stop. I am beginning to think that liberalism is not a political thought but sickness in the head!

      • 1 vote
      #1.8 - Fri Mar 30, 2012 3:31 AM EDT
      Reply

      Why did they kill him? They killed him because he deserved killing.

      • 8 votes
      Reply#2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:51 AM EDT

      However, the BBC said French Foreign Minister Alain Juppe responded: "If I were the father of such a monster, I would shut my mouth in shame."

      Sorry to say, but it seems that a few too many of the relatives of Islamic murderers feel an overwhelming sense of entitlement to sorrow for their captured or killed kin. Somehow, killing kids in school and ramming planes into buildings are feats to be proud of, according to their "religious playbook".

      The French police, soldiers, and government conducted themselves with the utmost professionalism, going so far as to offer to send the idiot's body back to Algeria for burial. If it were me, I'd drop him off at the nearest trash dump.

      • 11 votes
      Reply#3 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:56 AM EDT

      They are merely acting like familiy members of someone who was killed. It's only natural that they would have those feelings. What the guy did was wrong on every count but don't begrudge his family members for feeling the way that they do.

      • 1 vote
      #3.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 11:19 AM EDT

      He should be buried sewn in pig skins as a lesson to other Muslim scum.

      • 2 votes
      #3.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 4:04 PM EDT
      Reply

      Both of you echoed my thoughts exactly.

        Reply#4 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:57 AM EDT

        *sigh*

        • 1 vote
        Reply#5 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:57 AM EDT

        This is just the start. France is in deep trouble. The more Muslims you allow into your country, the more trouble you get. They multiply like rats too so good luck France. You are going to need it.

        • 6 votes
        Reply#6 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:02 AM EDT

        The same can be said about rabid bigots like you. You and your ilk add nothing constructive to any society.

        • 1 vote
        #6.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 11:20 AM EDT

        I am not the problem in France. Just sit back and watch, genius.

        • 1 vote
        #6.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:47 PM EDT

        Please "Lion", why doesn't your state do something useful like secede. Better for the rest of the union to be rid of a state with a majority population of deep racists.

          #6.3 - Fri Mar 30, 2012 2:32 AM EDT
          Reply

          The State of Algeria did the right thing in refusing to allow the body of Mohamed Merah to be buried in Algeria-they do not want his grave there. Of note is the fact that Merah's father in the same interview (verbaim in focus.de) also stated that Mohamed Merah had an Algerian passport and was registered with the Algerian Consulate in Toulouse,France since his birth (dual citizen). Merah was a criminal (15 juvenile cases),incarcerated for violent robbery, a recipient of social benefits- yet committing crimes (burgalaries, thefts,illegal activities etc) He was supposed to start serving his jail; sentence in April for 1 (one)month for driving w/o license. His father abandoned the family when he was six (6)yrs old. He was a career criminal turned terror aficienado and emulator- what is of interest is what did his Algerian Passport stamps indicate? He had so many weapons he could not have purchased with his own monies. Merah entered the State of Israel at the Allenby Bridge (meaning from Jordan) going to West Bank. While in Afgh/Pak border area he contracted Hepatitis A. Note also that the same Hebrew School in Toulouse is getting a lot of hate mail and threats (three kids and a rabbi were killed execution style by Merah and filmed)yet the hordes of Merah excusers blame the victims of the grisly murders.

          • 4 votes
          Reply#7 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:05 AM EDT
          Comment author avatarDadInAZ-3698986Expand Comment Comment collapsed by the community

          Exterminate the Muslims. They behave like animals. If they don't get their way or you don't conform to their ways, they kill you. Time to cleanse the earth of these scumbags.

          • 3 votes
          Reply#8 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:08 AM EDT

          "They could have arrested him and had him face justice" Yep, just dust off the ol' guillotine! Note to father: Dead is DEAD, you twit!

          • 2 votes
          Reply#9 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:26 AM EDT

          Dad. Animals do not behave like this. They are better then that!

          • 4 votes
          Reply#10 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:27 AM EDT

          This young man was an ungrateful, France gave asylum to his parents and him to live in peace and He is a murderer.What a disappointment for France to have as many refugees paid after bad.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#11 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:28 AM EDT

          Why did they kill him? He probably knew too much, and would be an embarrassment.

            Reply#12 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:28 AM EDT

            he went to isreal. that sounds fishy. someone smell mossad behind the curtains?

              Reply#13 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:29 AM EDT

              what i find hillarious is that you people constantly blame a entire religion for what few people do! have you forgotten that your jails are full of christain and jews that have raped, killed, stolen, child molesters, etc. as well?? but you seem to want to lamblast islam as if it is the problem! every religion has extreme loons in it...i.e.-catholic priests...but you dont blame christainity for the raping of young alter boys...so why would you correlate islam with killing??? the world is full of crazies and hiding behind a computer saying to kill all muslims, sounds to me kinda like the same mindset that the few stupid people running around killing themselves does!

              • 2 votes
              Reply#14 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:31 AM EDT

              Steve, i agree with you... we have bunch of extremists amongst us !!! deplorable comments. This gunman not only killed jews but 3 muslim french army men as well. some people are blinded by sheer hatred for islam and want to kill all muslims

                #14.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:38 AM EDT

                Steven

                The difference here is that islam commands muslims to kill (murder) non muslims! The example you give about christians killling, raping etc. is incorrect in many ways. Anybody claiming to be a christian who kills, steals, rapes etc. is not a christian. They are liars, criminals etc. These people only pretend to be christians! As an example, scriptures states that stealing is a crime and must be punished. Raping somebody in God's eyes is a capital crime which means that the rapist deserves death for what he did. Get it yet?

                Anybody can call themselves a christian. It's how you live your life that proves who you are. You won't find a single verse in the bible that says, "it's ok to steal...", or, "if you rape somebody just say sorry..".

                Islams mandate is to "kill all non believers". The koran is based on hatred and death. What this savage did, he did exactly as islam commands. You don't hear about Jews blowing up airliners or buildings. You don't hear about christians walking into restaurants or schools and setting off explosives but you do read about muslims doing all these things on a regular basis in the name of islam. Muslims are commanded to use all means available to advance islam. All non muslims must submit to islam or be killed for thier disbelief. Understand this one thing, YOU are one of those non muslim disbelievers so you are a target just as these little innocent girls where! Marinate on that for a while. Islam is the most hate filled, murderous, lie infested religion in human history. Go on youtube and listen for yourself what muslim clerics are teaching muslims to do. Killing is a mandatory action for "true" muslims.

                Before you post your comments next time I strongly suggest you get your facts straight. You will save yourself a lot of humiliation.

                • 1 vote
                #14.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:45 AM EDT

                Simon, i disagree with you. Islam only allows killing a non muslim in defence. this is utterly wrong as to what u have said. Muslims who kill out of their own satanic ways will rot in hell if u ask any muslim. stop preaching hatred.

                  #14.3 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:56 AM EDT

                  Dan Still.

                  You claim that I'm preaching hatred? It's very easy to prove who is lying and who is being truthful here. Read for yourself what the "holy" koran has to say about non muslims.

                  When a muslim declares that islam is a religion of peace, he/she is either ignorant of the koran or is deceitfully thinking of "peace" as it extends to those only within the muslim community. According to the koran, "muhammad is the apostle of allah. Those who follow muhammad are merciful to one another, but ruthless to unbelievers"

                  sura 48:29 "Kill the mushrikun (unbelievers aka. non muslims) wherever you find them, and capture them and besiege them and lie in wait for them in each and every ambush".

                  The word "jihad" actually stems from the arabic root word J-H-D. That word simply means "to strive". Islams ultimate goal is to literally eradicate all other religions & faiths except for islam from the world. Anybody who rejects islam is to be eradiated (murdered). Muhammad encourages his followers to spreak islam by force.

                  surah 2:216 "warfare is ordained for you though it is hateful unto you; but it may happen that ye hate a thing which is good for you, and it may happen that ye love a thing which is bad for you."

                  The koran itself warns muslims "do not take jews or christians as your friends". During the arab conquests, jews and christians alike were massacred, and synagogues and churches destroyed. A muslim phrase often quoted in the middle east region is: "On saturday we kill the jews and sunday we kill the christians".

                  There are over 100 verses in the koran advocating the use of violence to spreak this demonic religion called islam. There are exactly 123 verses in the koran about killing and fighting. Among these verses you will read the following.

                  -truly, allah loves those who fight

                  -fight and slay the pagens (non muslims) wherever you find them.

                  -chop off their hands and chop off their fingertips

                  -when you meet unbelievers, chop off their heads

                  -those who follow muhammad are ruthless to unbelievers

                  Who's lying now? Care to prove to the readers how I'm lying and spreading "hatred" now?

                  

                  

                  • 1 vote
                  #14.4 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 2:20 PM EDT

                  Want me to make a little study of the utter viciousness of the Old Testament, Simon?

                    #14.5 - Fri Mar 30, 2012 2:35 AM EDT

                    I think he should take you up on your offer cus Doesn't come close John. The hebrew conquest of Judea and Canaan in Second Millenial BCE where there has been a Jewish presence ever since cannot be the equvallent to the Muslim conquest of most of the ancient Civilized world within 125 years of the inception of Islam.

                    • 1 vote
                    #14.6 - Sun Apr 1, 2012 12:01 PM EDT
                    Reply

                    On Tuesday, Merah's father, Mohamed Benalen Merah, lashed out at French authorities for killing his son (article)

                    That moron wanted his son alive!! the son who murdered 7 people! that moron has no shame! he is blaming the french for killing that murder?! I hope Franch and the rest of the world kill all those murderers everywhere!

                    • 1 vote
                    Reply#15 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:32 AM EDT

                    French police did not kill an innocent person (Mohamad Merah) as the father implies. They destroyed an animal. Huge difference.

                    • 3 votes
                    Reply#16 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:34 AM EDT

                    They say he wore a necklace with Johnny Depp's picture.

                      Reply#17 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:38 AM EDT

                      Wow. His father has a lot of nerve.

                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#18 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:41 AM EDT
                      simpfoooDeleted

                      "The more Muslims you allow into your country, the more trouble you get. They multiply like rats too"

                      Of course this is what is desired by those who are pulling the strings. All of whats happening in the world today is to degrade muslims and calumnize them. I am 33 years old, and have been a muslim all my life (proudly) and have never felt an iota of violence towards even a mere ant. All life has value. That is what we believe in. If muslims really are they way media so aggresively attempting to potray them, this world would have ended a LONG time ago. If muslims really are against peace in the world then i'd say we really missed a golden chance to rid the world of non-muslims.

                      Muslims' rule in Indian Subcontinent.

                      My ancestors ruled the indian subcontinent for 700 years. I am a mughal, and all hindustanis can vouch for the kind and glorious 700 years those had been under a just muslim rule. 700 years was enough time to cleanse the indian subcontinent of non-muslims but we did not do that, because that is not who were are. We stand for peace, love and compassion. to this date, there are more hindus living in the subcontinent than there are muslims, that is because we believe in peace, love, compassion and tolerance. (obviously there are limits to our tolerance, we are a modest people and we uphold modesty and morality)

                      Muslims Rule in Europe

                      When moors ruled in europe for 700 years, they had enough time to eardicate the infidels, cleanse Europe of non-muslims, did they do that? NO! they did not! they lived in harmony with other religions. Other religions were even allowed to follow their religious teachings freely. Islam made rich and significant contribution to western art and culture, the story of the mysterious and misunderstood Moors, the Islamic society that ruled in Spain for 700 years, whose legacy was virtually erased from Western history. Why? ask yourself that question, who would want to erase the glorious history of Muslims' rule in spain?

                      Contributions of Muslim to the World we live in:

                      The Moors had contributed tremendously to Spain and other European regions through the knowledge they spread between the early 700s and the late 1400s. They had brought along with them knowledge of science, medicine and mathematics, and also constructed important centers for the people such as mosques, hospitals
                      and libraries that transformed Spain from what it was.

                      Arabian scientists were some of the earliest to bring knowledge into Spain. Astronomy was also one of the subjects on which they focused, and it is a science well studied by the Arabs of those days because they could use the stars to determine direction. It was due to all this intellectual influence in and around this period that Universities began to spring up. The result of this was a strong regard for education, and so, knowledge began to blossom (Ghiles, 1983).

                      Through the years 827 to 1091 AD Islam spread to Spain, Sicily, North Africa, Syria, Palestine and South East Asia. The Shiites sects as well as the Sunni sects had been responsible for the establishment of the social cultures in these areas. With the advent of the Crusaders, the region of Palestine and Israel became divided and so has the social relationships between the different religions (A Concise History of Islam and the Arabs 2004).

                      During the Arab influence in Spain and other parts of Europe, Christians and
                      Muslims sometimes managed to live side by side. However, there were conflicts
                      that arose. In addition to this, similar sentiments existed between the Jews and
                      Muslims. When there was peace in the region, it resulted in science and arts
                      flourishing, which was typically the case.

                      Hostilities were not rampant everywhere, and as a result the presence of the Moors brought significant development to the people there. It is because of peace prevailing among the inhabitants of Spain that it was the brightest part of Europe. By the word ‘brightest’, it means that a large part of Europe was sunk in darkness. This darkness was in the form of ignorance that was caused largely by conflict. Had Muslims, Christians and Jews in these parts along with other warring factions made peace, they too would have benefited the way that Spain did (Carew, 1992, 248-77).

                      During the Moorish period in Spain, Poet-King Mu-Tamid had succeeded in establishing an assembly of several great intellectuals. The most famous Arab poetry as well was recorded during this period. The caliph had to flee from Syria for Toledo in 750, resulting in the center of the Islamic world being transported to Spain. Further, the result of this change was that there was an increased presence of Moors in the peninsula. This increase in the number of these people meant that there was construction of beautiful palaces, mosques, and fortresses (Carew, 1992, 248-77).

                      PLEASE STOP DEMONIZING THE BEST OF THE PEOPLE ON THIS PLANET

                      "MUSLIMS"

                        Reply#20 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:45 AM EDT

                        Many or most people who post here are stupid enough to believe your taqiyya bs. Many aren't and the number is growing. In the face of worldwide evidence, your statements are delusional.

                        • 3 votes
                        #20.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:14 AM EDT

                        In response to your post well said but understand this america is deverse in culture a melting pot of people that built this country,furthermore evetbody has there say right or wrong and it all starts with our leaders ability to lead the people of their nation but put this all aside the history lesson was well taken by me even though you left out some good and bad but that is what makes us human beings!

                          #20.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:43 AM EDT

                          Ha! Taqiyya! I was raised Muslim by an Arab father (who spoke Arabic, by the way), going to the mosque weekly, around many other Muslims including the Imam of our masjid and I still learned the word taqiyya from PAMELA GELLER when I was 30 something! I'm still not quite sure what it means and I have no clue as to where she (and you) got the term. And to the RACIST who posted his "facts" about Islam and the Quran...ummm, I must be the worst Muslim ever because I haven't killed any non-Muslims. I don't think I've ever even poked a non-Muslim in the eye, not that I haven't wanted to considering my in-laws are non-Muslims.

                          Muslims don't spread Islam by the sword. We spread Islam through our actions and deeds. Jihad is wearing the scarf or having open conversations with others about Islam. What I'm doing right now is Jihad. We don't have missionaries that trade Jesus for food in impoverished countries. We don't hand out flyers and pester people by going door to door. Islam is growing fast and that's because the true religion, not what's been twisted by the fanatics, speaks for itself. Don't listen to the media or wherever it is you're getting your info on Islam. Open a Quran or ask a Muslim. The racism/bigotry will only end up hurting innocent people, including yourself in the long run. Once you're done terrorizing Muslims, who's next?? Is it your religion or race or culture? Maybe.

                            #20.3 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:44 AM EDT

                            Any country where Islam invades, the standards of living and human rights go down. Simple facts - before Islam took hold, the Arab world was the center of learning and science, now? Government and beliefs are locked in the dark ages. How many scientific advances out of Saudi Arabia with all their oil dollars? How many Nobel prizes out of Israel?

                            Basic beliefs: the Judeo-Christian Bible is a collection of writings from many people, developed across a period of hundreds or thousands of years, yet it is cohesive in its teachings: God loves all the world, and wishes the world peace and love. Islam is the collected writings of one man, a megalomaniac child molester, who had schemes of world domination. His teaching: any thing is acceptable when dealing with a non-believer, and non believers are sub humans to be enslaved or killed if they will not accept domination. End enticement: his god hates people so much that if a follower kills an innocent non-believer, he will be taken to "heaven" where he will live an eternity of debauchery. This is turning a benevolent God into a figure of a pimp: procuring virgins for his "johns", putting a hit on people he does not like. Somehow, that takes the image from being a supreme, good deity to being a powerful force for evil. Still one deity, but in a negative direction.

                              #20.4 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 10:06 AM EDT

                              Islam is a religion of hate. The reason for that is that Mohammad was a psychopath who taught a belief system which promoted jihad, murder, conquest, plunder, retribution, misogyny, polygamy, pedophilia, revenge, and hate toward non-Muslim infidels. Though the Koran gives lip service to treating other Muslims with respect and kindness, in reality, all the infidels are fair game. I am sick of hearing the brain-washed liberal morons in this country constantly repeating trite phrases such as "all religions are basically good" and "Islam is a religion of peace". Nothing could be further from the truth. Muslim radicals have a proclivity for murdering innocent and defenseless individuals. What unbelievable cowardice! I would venture a guess that eighty percent of the world's conflicts and killings are associated with Islamic groups. The true fraud of Islam is that Allah will reward those who have been good---not because they were inherently inclined to be righteous, but rather because they were mortally afraid of being bad. Any god, such as Allah, who desires an association with individuals who lack natural decency is truly a cretin. Within Islam, physical control over adherents is attained through mind control. One cannot even renounce Islam without being marked for death. Any religion that obtains converts under threat of death (Mohammad was famous for this tactic), and murders those who refuse to convert or who defect from the faith is bound to have a growing number of adherents. After a generation of two, time dims the memory of the barbaric and psychopathic acts committed against the forefathers, and brainwashing transforms the progeny of the forced converts into true believers who are willing to die for the fraudulent faith. Any Muslim believer who comes to accept the Quran as the literal spoken word of Allah is likely to become a terrorist because, realistically, the Quran is a terrorist handbook. I have first-hand knowledge of that fact, as I have read it in both Arabic and English. I believe that for those having an open mind, that characterization is indisputable.

                              • 2 votes
                              #20.5 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 10:42 AM EDT

                              Pakistani, your letter sounds very nice, however, you left out some very important details. Why?

                              For example. In retrospect, the Crusades probably allowed the western world a thousand years of freedom from the diabolical islamic religion. The crusaders stopped the expansion of the Islamic empire. This allowed Christianity to prosper in Europe which preserved the gospel for the rest of the world to receive.

                              The Crusades were a reaction to the muslim crusades against the entire world.
                              In the 7th century, the muslims took control of Jerusalem, and in the 11th century they began to hassle, kill, molest Christian pilgrims in the Jerusalem area. The muslim Turks even attacked Rome and Belgrade in 1456 A.D. The crusades were also in response to the cries of help from the eastern Byzantine Empire, which was very worried about the military threat to it from the Seljuk Turks. So if the Christians did not respond, the muslims would have conquered all of Europe and wiped out Christianity from the planet. Did this have any significance to Osama bin Laden's sick mind? The muslim high point in Europe ended when they were turned back from Vienna on September 11, 1683 A.D.

                              SPAIN UNDER THE MOORS
                              Neither was Spain under the muslim moors the jewel of islamic tolerance that it is often purported to be. In 920 A.D. all the inhabitants of Muez were put to the sword. Cordova, Zarajoza and Merida were burned to the ground, with all adult males executed and all women and children enslaved. In AD 1066 all the Jews of Grenada were slaughtered. In AD 1126, all the Christians of Grenada were deported to Morocco.

                              CARNAGE IN CONSTANTINOPLE
                              Under Mehmet II the Turks conquered the great Byzantine capital, Constantinople. On 29 May, 1453 A.D., waves of Turkish soldiers swept into Constantinople, the greatest city in the world at that time, and put it to the sword. Priceless libraries and irreplaceable works of art were burned, the population slaughtered, even in the Hagia Sophia, the greatest Christian church in the world at that time.

                              For centuries the Turks demanded an annual "blood levy" of Christian boys. Parents were forced to hand over one out of every five Christian boys for service in the Sultan's army as janissaries.

                              In 1860 over 12,000 Christians were slaughtered in Lebanon. In 1876 14,700 Bulgarians were murdered by the Turks. 200,000 Armenian Christians were slaughtered by the Turks in Bayazid in 1877. And in 1915 the Turks massacred over 1.5 million Armenian Christians. As recently as September 1922 the Turkish army destroyed the ancient city of Smyrna and murdered its 300,000 Christian population.

                              You clearly left out important details to cover up the crimes commited by this demonic religion of "peace" you call islam.
                              Never in human history has there been a more hate filled, murderous, lie infested religion such as islam. Don't treat people like they are stupid. It's very easy to learn the truth of islams history. You can spew your lies all you want but in the end the truth stands out over your perverted religion.

                              • 4 votes
                              #20.6 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 2:30 PM EDT

                              Oh, one final thought. I'm refering to your last line where you write:

                              PLEASE STOP DEMONIZING THE BEST OF THE PEOPLE ON THIS PLANET

                              "MUSLIMS"

                              The "best people on this planet"?! Really? The nazis saw themselves the same way and look what they did to the planet. We have not demonized muslims. YOU muslims have done that to yourselves. If the "best" people on this planet resort to murder, lies, deception and hatred to promote a demonic religion started by a lunatic named muhammad then I am happy not to be in the same class as you savages.

                              • 3 votes
                              #20.7 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 3:08 PM EDT

                              I am a (you guess what gets inserted here) and can vouch for the kind and glorious 700 years those had been under a just muslim rule. 700 years was enough time to cleanse the indian subcontinent of non-muslims but we did not do that, because that is not who were are. We stand for peace, love and compassion.

                              Gosh thats rich. You just can't make this stuff up....

                              Mr Pakistani 4118815,

                              you like your Arab Spring-fed Egyptian brethren are in deNile.

                              Thanks for bearing out what our challenge is

                                #20.8 - Sun Apr 1, 2012 12:14 PM EDT
                                Reply

                                "If I were the father of such a monster, I would shut my mouth in shame.” ONe of the best comments in the story. Islam has no shame!

                                • 2 votes
                                Reply#21 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:59 AM EDT

                                I

                                  Reply#22 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:00 AM EDT

                                  I've never commented on a news story before but I feel compelled today. Really??? Exterminate all Muslims?? I am baffled and hurt by the fact that racism and bigotry against Muslims is acceptable. Make no mistake, if you are making generalized negative statements about a group of people and/or calling for their extermination, segregation, etc...you are a RACIST. You are on par with a member of the KKK. Instead of "Muslim", insert "black" or "Jew"...that makes it unacceptable and so should using the word "Muslim" in your RACIST comments.

                                  As a Muslim woman, I am so disgusted and hurt by the comments I read on these stories. You are attacking my family and my culture and lifestyle. It is unwarranted and unjust that you would lump my family in with Mehar, etc and their actions. We are individuals. We aren't al-Qaida. We aren't Gaddafi. We aren't Khomeni. To hold me accountable for their actions is, really, unfathomable. Then to say we should ALL be exterminated??? That's painful and dangerous.

                                    Reply#23 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:02 AM EDT

                                    mandimae this is america, americans have no clue whats going on the world around them. No matter what, they have been injected with islampphobia. 99% of these racists never opened a quran. stay safe sister and be carful of these racists.

                                      #23.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:07 AM EDT

                                      Islam isn't a race no matter how many times you play the race card.

                                      • 1 vote
                                      #23.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:15 AM EDT
                                      Reply

                                      every time i come to a thread like this, i just shake my head at all the brainless morons that stereotype a religion of 2 billion people because of some lunatic kid. please stop you clowns

                                        Reply#24 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:04 AM EDT

                                        I don't know why I torture myself by reading the comments. Sometimes, I guess, I still don't believe that people act and speak that way. Of course, I have to remind myself that it's really easy to make these comments when you're cowering behind a computer. They don't like the word racist...how about bigot?? Hate criminal?

                                          #24.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:25 AM EDT

                                          Muslims stereotype themselves. 2 billion Muslims is something to deplore not respect. Those 2 billion are a calamity for the human race. As are you.

                                            #24.2 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 2:40 PM EDT
                                            Reply

                                            Religion of Peace?...Middle Least is gonna make a great parking lot

                                            • 1 vote
                                            Reply#25 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:10 AM EDT

                                            All you islamophobes. Did you read??? The soldiers he killed were Muslims as well. So obviously this guy did not have a vendeta against Jews. It is more against the government. So don't try to play the victim/religious war card. He did not do this in the name of Islam. He did it because he was "pissed off" at the government.

                                            Agreed what he has done is completely wrong. He is a murderer. So all you biggots, lay off with the insults against a religion you don't even know. All you dumb ignorant intolerant knowldge is based on TV series, etc...

                                            • 4 votes
                                            Reply#26 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:11 AM EDT

                                            We know all we need to know about Muslims. Unlike your condition, Islamophobia is based on fact and reason.

                                              #26.1 - Thu Mar 29, 2012 2:30 PM EDT

                                              Ibjack, you're of simple mind. You hold simple views.. Little people harbor irrational prejudices. So it's always been. And that why people like you rarely find themselves in the position to govern anything. Just as it should be.

                                                #26.2 - Fri Mar 30, 2012 2:44 AM EDT

                                                Sam-279394

                                                All you islamophobes. Did you read??? The soldiers he killed were Muslims as well. So obviously this guy did not have a vendeta against Jews. It is more against the government.

                                                Obviously he had no vendetta against Jews. After killing a couple fellow muslim-(what they are best at doing 'cus usually there is no Jew or Christian nearby) he absolutely did not go out of his why to drive across town and randomly strayed in to a Jewish day-school. I mean he just as easliy could have parked in front of a station full of unsuspecting Gendarmes. Apparently the jewish children at school are more representative of French Governmental target than gendarmes or City Hall.

                                                Do you really believe what you write or is your agenda that much more important.

                                                  #26.3 - Sun Apr 1, 2012 12:40 PM EDT
                                                  Reply
                                                  Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                                                  You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                  As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.