
Ismail Zitouny / Reuters
Men prepare to bury the body of Abdel Baset al-Megrahi at a cemetery in Janzour, near Tripoli, on Monday.
NEW YORK -- The death of the only man convicted in the 1988 Lockerbie bombing has left some victims' relatives relieved and others raising questions about his guilt and whether others went unpunished.
Abdel Baset al-Megrahi, a former Libyan intelligence official, died Sunday of cancer, his family said. His death renewed pleas from some victims' relatives for further investigation of the bombing.
"It closes a chapter but it doesn't close the book. We know he wasn't the only person involved," Frank Dugan, president of the group Victims of Pan Am Flight 103, said from Alexandria, Va.
Al-Megrahi was convicted of blowing up Pan Am Flight 103 over the Scottish town of Lockerbie on Dec. 21, 1988. The bombing killed 270 people, including 189 Americans. Syracuse University in central New York was particularly hard hit: 35 students on the way home for Christmas break died in the bombing.
Abdel Baset al-Megrahi, the man convicted of blowing up Pan Am Flight 103 over Scotland, died after a long illness. NBC's Richard Engel reports.
$2.7 billion in compensation
Libyan ruler Moammar Gadhafi handed over al-Megrahi and a second suspect to Scottish authorities after years of punishing U.N. sanctions. In 2003, Gadhafi acknowledged responsibility, though not guilt, for the bombing and paid compensation of about $2.7 billion to victims' families.
Some relatives attended al-Megrahi's trial in the Netherlands. When he was released to Libya from a Scottish prison in 2009 on humanitarian grounds — he was supposedly close to death — they were outraged when al-Megrahi returned to a hero's welcome from Gadhafi and then lived far longer than the few months the doctors had predicted.
Susan Cohen of Cape May Court House, N.J., whose daughter was among the Syracuse University students on the flight, said al-Megrahi deserved no compassion.
"The fact that he was able to get out and live with his family these past few years is an appalling miscarriage of justice. There was no excuse for that," Cohen said Sunday. "He should have died in the Scottish prison. He should have been tried in the United States and faced capital punishment."
Dec. 21, 1988: Pan Am Flight 103, exploded over Lockerbie Scotland killing all 259 people on board as well as 11 on the ground. It was not immediately known a bomb exploded on board. NBC's Tom Brokaw, Peter Kent and Robert Hager report.
The views of other victims' families on al-Megrahi's role in the bombing vary widely.
"Megrahi is the 271st victim of Lockerbie," said David Ben-Ayreah, who represents some British families of victims. He attended the trial and still believes al-Megrahi was not responsible for the bombing.
'Very happy'
But Eileen Walsh, a Glen Rock, N.J., resident whose father, brother and sister died in the explosion, said she was "very happy" to hear about al-Megrahi's death. She had just attended Mass on Sunday when she received numerous text messages.
"I'm glad he's gone, but there's no real closure. There's nothing but a bad taste in my mouth," she said.
"My mother died of cancer in 2004, and because of him, three of the most important people in her life weren't there to help her in her time of need," Walsh said.
Al-Megrahi was found guilty under Scottish law of secretly loading a suitcase bomb onto a plane at Malta's Luqa Airport, where he was head of operations for Libyan Arab Airlines in December 1988.
The former Libyan intelligence officer Abdel Baset al-Megrahi, who was convicted of taking part in the 1988 Lockerbie bombing but was released after eight years for health reasons, has died in Libya of prostate cancer. NBC's Jim Maceda reports from London.
The suitcase was transferred at Frankfurt to another flight and then onto New York-bound Pan Am Flight 103 at London's Heathrow airport, concluded Scottish judges sitting at a converted Dutch military base selected as a neutral trial venue.
Al-Megrahi, who was handed over by Gadhafi under a U.N.-brokered deal, always insisted he was merely an airline executive, not a Libyan intelligence agent as prosecutors charged.
Miscarriage of justice?
Al-Megrahi's co-defendant was acquitted of all charges. Al-Megrahi insisted he also had nothing to do with the bombing. Those who believed him got a boost in 2007 when a three-year investigation by a Scottish tribunal found that new evidence — and old evidence withheld from trial — suggested that al-Megrahi "may have suffered a miscarriage of justice." Its 800-page report prompted an appeal on al-Megrahi's behalf, but by then his fate was in the hands of politicians in London, Tripoli and Edinburgh, all of whom jockeyed for position as Libya rebuilt its ties with Britain and al-Megrahi's health deteriorated.
Still protesting his innocence, al-Megrahi dropped the appeal in a bid to clear the path for his release on compassionate grounds.
Al-Megrahi's death should not be an excuse to stop trying to find out who was behind the bombing, Cohen said. She called on U.S. and British officials to "dig even deeper" into the case.
The Scottish government said Sunday that it will continue investigating the Lockerbie bombing.
U.K. Prime Minister David Cameron, visiting the United States on Sunday, said that al-Megrahi should never have been freed.
However, Britain's ITV News reported that Cameron dismissed calls for a new inquiry into al-Megrahi's conviction, saying the court case was "properly run and properly dealt with."
Read more coverage from Britain's ITV News
Bert Ammerman of River Vale, N.J., lost his brother in the bombing. He blames the U.S. and Britain for failing to track all leads in the case and noted that Gadhafi's former spy chief was arrested in March in Mauritania.
"He holds the key to what actually took place in Pan Am 103," Ammerman said. "He knows what other individuals were involved and, more importantly, what other countries were involved."
After Gadhafi's fall, Britain asked Libya's new rulers to help fully investigate but they put off any probe.
"Ironically, 24 years later, I now have more confidence in the new Libyan government than the British or American governments to find the truth because I believe Libya would like the truth to come out to show that they were not the only country involved," Ammerman said.
Jim Swire, whose 19-year-old daughter, Flora, died in the bombing, is a leading voice for some of the British families who believe al-Megrahi was innocent. Swire, who attended the trial in the Netherlands, asked for further inquiry from the Scottish government.
''I've been satisfied for some years that this man had nothing to do with the murder of my daughter and I grit my teeth every time I hear newscasters say 'Lockerbie bomber has died,'" Swire told the BBC on Sunday. ''This is a sad day."
'Smelled of a deal for oil'
Al-Megrahi's brother Mohammed told Reuters that a funeral would take place on Monday.
"My brother was surrounded by his wife, children and his mother as he took his last breath. He was too sick to utter anything on his deathbed," his brother Abdulhakim added. "We will always tell the world that my brother was innocent."
Senator Charles Schumer of New York, who wanted the Libyan government that took over after Gadhafi's ouster and killing by rebels to take al-Megrahi into custody, said his return to Libya was a major injustice.
"The whole deal smelled of a deal for oil for this man's freedom and that was almost blasphemy given what a horrible person he was and the terrible destruction and tragedy that he caused," Schumer said. "I don't know if we'll ever get to the bottom of it now."
Msnbc.com staff, ITV News, The Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report.
More world news from msnbc.com and NBC News:
- Pakistan blocks Twitter -- but fails to stop tweets
- NATO summit prompts little buzz on streets of Kabul
- Olympic torchbearers race to cash in
- A random act of kindness lifts spirits in London
- 800-year-old tree falls to illegal loggers
- Japan mayor: I wouldn't hire tattooed Depp, Gaga
- Library opened by Mark Twain falls victim to cuts
Follow us on Twitter: @msnbc_world


This Terrorist Looks like Gene Simmons or Paul Stanley's Brother of the overrated Heavy metal group, Kiss.
They don't really know if they ever got the right guy.
$2.7 billion Compenation for #270 dead passengers, that's a lot of bread my Man. A lot of people got super rich.
Pan Am became History.
Here come the Judge, Here come the Judge........
While no amount of money can compensate for the loss of a loved one, $10 million per victim that was paid by the Libyan government certainly left the victims families pretty well off.
The truth is the al-Megrahi was released in order to help BP secure oil drilling rights in Libya. The timing was just too coincidental for it to be anything else as BP's drilling rights were approved within a month or two of al-Megrahi's release. While I have no doubt that there were others involved, I do not buy the protestations of innocence from al-Megrahi or his supporters. Unless the new Libyan government cooperates, which I find highly improbable, I highly doubt we will ever know the full story or who else was involved in the bombing. The new Libyan government is being slowly but surely taken over by Islamists and they are not likely to help any western nation in investigating this incident.
Ok, this is already been reported, move on ... Lybia wont give up squat.
thank god that mutt is dead
still a mutt
:)
At least he is in hell. He got to spend time with his family, yet he never gave many a chance to do the same. I would not be so forgiving. He should have died in prison. Way to screw up Scotland.
May you rot in hell you POS!!!!!
Everyone knows the bombing was an Iranian operation and was payback for the USS Vincennes blowing IR Flight 655 out of the sky and killing 295 innocent people. The USS Vincennes attack of IR Flight 655 was done to support Saddam and to stop Iran from continuing the war after they had obtained the upper hand after we had given Saddam WMDs to attack Iran. The US did not want war with Iran and figured it could extort money from Gadaffi. The people who claimed the shirt was bought from a particular shop as a means of tracing the bomb were paid off by the US to lie and to people received $1.3 million each for lying. Bank transactions have proved this. The U.S. did not want to admit the treachery of Pan Am Flight 103 was the result of U.S. treachery for IR Flight 655. The commander of the Vincennes lied about every circumstance, and this was proved in international tribunals and with flight black box evidence. The U.S. was mad at Gadaffi at the time because of his support of other terrorist bombing and used this to get at him. While Gadaffi paid $2.7 billion for killing 259 people the U.S. only paid $100 million for 295 Iranians. But, the ignorant and propagandized Americans believe whatever their government and media tells them, 99% of it is lies.
99% of what every government says is lies.
@Joseph
If you had said the lockerbie bombing was in retaliation for the April 1986 Bombings of Libya by Ronald Reagan, which themselves were in retaliation for several other terrorist attacks attributed to and or celebrated by Qaddafi and the Libyan Government....I seriously doubt that Qaddafi cared about the Iranians, He certainly didn't care about his own people...he might have been pissed that "We" targeted him and his family though...
See you in hell.
Steve-2057180
I'll look down upon you from Heaven.
Figure of speech, I don't believe in either one. They are fairy-tales told to children.
Steve-2057180 said: "They are fairy-tales told to children."
So the truth comes out from you. Believe what you want.
Just wait until you're on your deathbed.
SAD!
L-123, this will be my last post on this subject;
I appreciate your point of view, but what I find "Sad" is the need for some (not you specifically) to either have some great threat of punishment or promise of some great reward in order to lead their lives morally and ethically. I am more impressed by someone who does the "right" things because they know there right for that reason alone.
It is really not necessary to spew bile about your disgust for OUR beliefs.How far do you have to go to escape it? Far ,far away? Into your own mind? If it makes you feel any better,seeing as how almost everyone[ high 6+ billion say] has a belief system in a higher power,perhaps you are not trapped in the asylum,but something less than you are able to comprehend.Monotheism being the pinnacle of such thought. PS I'm afraid I can't come up with the term,but you're playing tricks with words.If you are American,YOU have been influenced by Christianity,and YOUR moral compass was derived from western thought on the matter
@pained, semantics?
Joseph,
"Everyone knows.."
No they don't, and especially not you. Your entire post is fiction. Go back to your mom's basement and try again.
To: Joseph Zrnchik
Great post!
Ahhhh, good to see that not 'all' American's are stupid ignorant fools.
Thanks!
stop taking crap from these towel headed radical cowardly cock sucking bastard's when they have their meeting's that show on tv ranting kill americans and infidal's it is time for the drone's if they don't tow the rope in the direction of democracy of the world, collatoral damage so what. killing their own people, you don't see the high up's putting bomb's on their back's. IRAN, LIBYA & anyother dicktator run country, your end is near, your young people arn't going to put up with you much longer. come on all you beautiful young muslim's, rise up put them out of business, i know that if you ask with the free world's help, we will get rid of these whore monger's. come on all you youing people rise up
To; To: Joseph Zrnchik
Joey mi boy, you're terribly well informed and brillient. What are you and I doing among all of this dumb-arse riff-raff on this site? LOL!
We'll never know, huh? :)
TheAZCowBoy, Tombstone, AZ.
You misspelled "brilliant".
how do you explain the morality of buddhists? most buddhists are better than the (self)back-patting, vengeance-loving, hate-spewing , flag-waving, money-grubbing, so-called "christians" on these boards
don't break your arm patting yourself on your back, pained1. because you have clearly learned the oft-decried by the right, public-school trick of making stuff up to raise your self-esteem
western-style thought goes back well before christianity, to the ancient greeks and then the romans. but the back-patters want to take all the credit as if they have some special, god-given ability that eludes the rest of the world that doesn't march to their little book. and that somehow their spit doesn't stink just as much as the rest of the worlds
Great article, would not be too surprised if he were a fall guy. I have few good memories other than personal for the 1980's, it seemed one big charade then, worse as time gone by.
The book will never be closed. But the closing of the casket is an improvement.
There are many in Libya who know the truth -- and who are probably still chuckling that al Maghrabi took the fall for the masterminds behind terror attacks all around the world. Since Qaddafi is gone, however, most of those involved have now fled the capitol and are no longer secure behind officials in high places. They will die knowing they 'got away with something' but the rest of the world hardly thinks Libya has made a complete and total change for the good.
Hard not to agree,W. I mourn for my country,and the west every day.
Shame on Britain and Scotland for reneging on thier agreement that he would STAY in their prisons until the end rather than having his trial here in the US like we originally requested. May those involved in the oil for terrorist exchange be haunted by that choice all their days and never know true peace. You sold your souls for a few barrels of oil. Hope you spent your 30 pieces of silver wisely.
One can only hope his last few days were filled with pain EQUAL to the pain the families of those who were lost on Pam 103 have experienced EVERY day for the last 30 years. Its no less than he deserves.
Only a fool would believe anything the US government and/or media has to say about this US conspiracy against Messer al-Megrahi. [See my other post today about US paying 2 key witnesses $4m for purjured testimoney to gain their conviction against 'one more victim' of the Great Satan].
Whooppe. it's bad enough that the Great Satan paid the two key witnesses $4m dollars in the Lockerbie bombing trial to present the 'right' testimony and get Messer al Magrahi convicted and then swore them to silence' as part of the bribe to avoid future problems, and now they come out with this "Well, it's not over til its over" Bull Caca. Dear Great Satan, indeed you are a piece of caca and a 'baby 'killer' on two continents too boot - so, you go take a flying fluck at the moon, OK killer?
May you have found 20 Ugly, shriveled, wrinkly, smelly virgins upon your entrance to your final resting place.
About damn time! Rot in Hell.
....wish him rot in hell without any peace (no virgenes for a change for this Arab)!
What they never explain is all the virgins the suicide bombers are suppose to get are pigs!
never rest in peace. you peice of s$#t!! tell osuma and his sons the usa says hi!!! and put another log on the fire, many more sumbags are on their way so make room!!!!! damm hell must be hugh!!!!
Wow, how nice of him getting to take his last breath with family when so many went up in a ball of fire. Maybe he's already feeling the heat. I'd like to take a dump on his grave.
good ridance may you burn in hell with the rest of your radical muslim brthers
Please tell the location of his grave so, we can all piss on it.
great idea !!
@ed castile; your too kind!!! i was thinking #2 on his grave!! oh well thats just me!!!
oh I can do #2 as well.lol
With a side of bacon....
read the caption under the pic.. his grave is in Tripoli....ROAD TRIP!!!
When you lose loved ones in an act of terror such as this and September 11, there is no sense of justice no matter whether the terrorist dies in prison or dies elsewhere. So he's dead now. I hope he suffered terribly.
So, why are the really BIG time genocider War Criminals' like George Bush, Dick Cheney, Condi Rice, Don Rumsfeld, Nobel Peace Prize Laureate Obama and 'the wicked witch of the West' Hillary Clinton still running around 'pushing their memoirs' and/or giving speeches 'for pay?'
Why Libya resorted to killing of innocent air travellers when this was not retaliation of killings of Libyans by US or any of its allies? Libya was never provoked and still this gruesome attacks by Muslims =the savages. Can Obama Hillary or Bush explain us? Now that bomber and Qaddafi are dead people celebrate. Justice- Judea Christian is served.
take your fairy tales elsewhere.
(((yawn))) Get the 'true' facts fool!
I hope he had a painful death, and the he rotted slowly from the inside out!
why don't Muslims eat pork ?cause that would make them cannibals...!!
When this terrorist was alive, why didn't we send a drone to drop a bomb on wherever he was located? That would have been a reasonable end to this murderers life; one well deserved!
No further investigation will be done by the Brittish, unfortunately. They traded this POS for oil rights. Others were definitely involved but will never be charged. Brittan has closed the book on this - essentially oil and money are the new religion and the 270 innocent people that were murdered were collateral damage.
The wealthy involved with the oil business ruled in this case. Making billions of dollars meant more to them than the lives lost. This is the way of the world these days. The rich are getting richer and the poor (including the former middle class) are getting poorer.
The Good Ole U S of A. I bet if was blowing up oil wells he would be dead.
GOOD!!! 1 less bastard to worry about!!!! His Allie(his God) will be waiting for him in Hell !!!!! Ding Dong the dick is dead!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hope bunch more like him dies or gets killed also.!!!!!!!!!!! Drop a atom bomb on the whole damn country over there and get rid of them all,the woman are no better than the men,kill them all like we did Japan.
Ah this poor guy. Wasn't he supposed to die three years ago?
How do we know for sure he is dead? I say we drag his body through Tripoli to make sure he's good and dead. Then we can spit on the corpse, bury him face down with a pig and piss on his grave. THEN we will know the muslim dog is dead.