
Adnan Abidi / Reuters
Manohar Lal Sharma, center, lawyer for defendants accused in a gang rape, speaks outside a district court in New Delhi on Thursday.
The attorney representing three men charged with gang rape and murder in India told an interviewer that the woman who died and her male companion were to blame for the attack, which took place on a moving bus in New Delhi, according to a report published Thursday.
"Until today I have not seen a single incident or example of rape with a respected lady," Manohar Lal Sharma said, according to the Bloomberg report. "Even an underworld don would not like to touch a girl with respect."
The Dec. 16 attack left the 23-year-old physiotherapy student and her companion, who was also beaten, bleeding on a highway. The woman died from her injuries two weeks later in a Singapore hospital.
Sharma, who is representing three of the five individuals charged in the attack, said Wednesday that his clients would plead not guilty to all charges in the case. Two other men have been charged in the attack, and a third was implicated but will be tried separately because he is a minor.
The lawyer's comments, which echoed those by some conservative religious and political figures, were likely to meet with more outrage from India’s urban middle class, which has spearheaded fierce protests against the government and police for their perceived failure to protect women from violence.
But they reflected a traditional chauvinism that is still held by many in the populous country.
"Guilt is not one-sided," Indian spiritual leader Asaram Bapu, told followers earlier in the week, adding that if the woman had pleaded with her six attackers in God's name, and told them she was of the "weaker sex," they would have relented, Reuters reported.
Mohan Bhagwat, a conservative pro-Hindu politician, weighed in with his view that rape occurs only in Indian cities, because women there adopt western lifestyles, but not in rural India.
But that view is contradicted by data, Reuters reported, citing the National Commission for Women, which has documented a pattern of gang rape and sexual humiliation of lower caste women in rural India.
Bhaskara Rao, who heads the New Delhi-based policy think tank said Bhagwat's comments reflected a traditional, rural society amid a country in transition.
"The people who are there in the police, judiciary, politics — they are old minds trying to deal with new problems," she said.
Reuters contributed to this report.
Related reports:
- Lawyer: Trio in India gang rape case will plead not guilty
- India gang rape case: Accused duo offer to testify against the others
- Father of rape victim: Hang the monsters who did this
- PhotoBlog: Amid outrage over gang rape, murder, calls for tougher punishment for sex crimes


So... is this the "she wouldn't have been raped if she didn't have a vagina" defense?
Reminds me of the movie Ted when Mark W is walking home and Milan Kunis' character asks if he wants a ride because its not safe for him to walk alone at night and he says..."but if I get raped it'll be my fault for what I'm wearing"
This is one defense attorney who desperately needs to be vigorously sodomised twice a day with the furry end of a broomstick.
Well, I certainly hope he enjoyed his career in law up until now... because it's definitely over after this. Either he's going to be forced out or someone will try to kill him. I'm normally a peaceful person but... preferably the latter move will prove successful. Because you can't fix stupid.
So their defense for rape is to blame the victims by saying they weren't respectable? So what does their version of respectable mean: Gang rapists? How the ** can that even work as a defense? Oh wait, I know! In neanderthal countries where woman are treated like property instead of as actual people, unspeakably disgusting things like this happen all the time.
And if their excuse for the woman wasn't pathetic enough, they never even offered an excuse for killing the male. What, was that just extra?
Wow, what barbaric scum! I'm sure even the most "dis-respectable" woman in that country is infinitely more respectable than any of these low lifers. That goes from the rapists all the way through to the lawyers and anyone in the court or in any form of media who would buy that garbage excuse even for a second. And that's putting it nicely. They are all scum.
WTF
Talk about being completely outside your got dang mind, bet he would change his tune real quick if some scumbags raped and beat his azz with a metal bar.
He must have been having drinks with some of our politicians of late, talk about one of the most dumbazz statements ever.
Hang the attorney.
I hope the masses turn on him and rip him to shreds.
They're just "Americanizing"! They got our gurgers, our jeans, and our music. Now they're using our rape defense! Hey, it's worked for generations here! Worth a try!
@ ORB 1943 post 1.2,
He is that person!
He is one sick bastard and a sorry piece of @!$%# his mother produced.
These sorry sacks of @!$%#! seriously...blame women?...yes keep blaming women for the ACTIONS of the men... What a load of horse@!$%#! What the hell is happening to this world? eh? You primitive retards over there in India need to wake up to the fact you cannot treat women this way.
When is it "illegal to not be respected?" If this is the case, then the rapists and their attorney, who have apparently written their own laws, are now vigilantes. Vigilantism is illegal. Act committed while being a vigilante are still crimes, and as in this case, the crime is murder. It's a lose/lose scenario either way.
Indians--perhaps a definition of what it means to respect another is needed. Obviously your attornies have no idea what it means.
As usual, when there is NO defense, it's easy to muddy the water with such tripe. They should throw the attorney in jail with the raping murderers. I'll bet when there's a full moon, (like in the shower), he'll change his tune.
And feel good all of you that we still give India over $130 million a year in aide.
This is awful- but worse-not entirely surprising. There was an article here a few days ago that most of the protests were attended only by men because the few women who showed up were getting groped (in an ANTI RAPE PROTEST!!!)
Really, I'm just at a loss for words...
Oh Yes, it was the victim's fault. Put her on trial, ....wait a minute we can't ......she was RAPED and MURDERED!!!
Hmmm... Perfect defense. Smart move on the lawyer's part insuring a slam dunk for the prosecution.
Wow...what a different world. Speaking of that, what makes Americans think that those Indian's(BTW-they're not even the cool kind of indians), give a flyin' rats azz what they think? Go over there and explain it to them. Tell them their old cultural ways are of the past, and they must embrace a new reality...take boxed DVD sets of Jersy Shore and Keeping up with the Kardashians, while you're at it. I'm not defending their brutal, backward actions(my opinion)... I am saying that we can't always look at the world through Western tinted glasses.
@JohnBrowning - But we're right and they're wrong. We have the biggest economy and biggest military, we win. But seriously, at least on this, we are right. There is no defense for the actions of these so-called "men". They should easily be looking at a capital crime with the death penalty if found guilty.
Just a note on something I read earlier: One of the things stated was that the lady's attackers had managed to pull her intestines out. This must've been an attack of extreme violence to go so far as to "gut" someone. If, indeed, she was disrespectable, why not just kill her outright? Why torture, rape, mutilate and gut her? I believe, when all the details are revealed, that hanging will be too good for these monsters. I'm waiting to see what justice India has the nerve to mete out.
I want to remind most of you that this was America, not too long ago - this was american men's defense less than 30 years ago, and MOST MEN did not get punished for raping women who "had it coming" because of the "way they dressed" or "looked at me".
And while Mr Akin and Mr Murdoch's comments arent as outrageous as these are, they really are not as far as off as the statements coming out of India
LEGITIMATE RAPE anyone?
I thank my lucky stars every single day that I live in America, but not just that - but that I was born and grew up and able to live as an adult during a time that is not as evil towards women as it used to be, and yes I am eternally grateful for the Feminist Movement and Progressives for making this a reality in America.
Conservatives can say whatever they want, but your most vocal pundits beat up on women and feminist almost daily for 'destroying america' - well, screw you - I like being able to avoid being raped because in your eyes im not a "respectable lady"...I really do appreicate THIS AMERICA.
If you dont, please - move to India.
There seems to be a huge gap in perception of ethics. This ethical plea by the lawyer to blame the victim seems so out of touch with reality that it's laughable. I would laugh like I do at clowns, but for the story and image of a young lady being raped and stabbed with iron rods into her vagina that I am nearly in shock instead. I can only hope to purge the descriptions of her horror from my mind lest it drive me insane with the sad thought.
Perhaps the lawyer is making his statement of extreme hyperbole so obscene because he secretly wants his own clients convicted and excecuted. If only they could make the death of the perpetrators as equally horrific.
God of Fate:
"Oh wait, I know! In neanderthal countries where woman are treated like property instead of as actual people, unspeakably disgusting things like this happen all the time."
Steubenville, Ohio.
"Guilt is not one-sided," Indian spiritual leader Asaram Bapu, told followers earlier in the week, adding that if the woman had pleaded with her six attackers in God's name, and told them she was of the "weaker sex," they would have relented, Reuters reported.
My question is --- what religion is this so called "spiritual Leader" affiliated with and why does the media refuse to mention it? I guarantee you that if he claimed to be Christian the leftist media would make that the headline.
And Jessica --- name one instance that proves your assertion that "your most vocal pundits beat up on women". Now feminist (read radical here) are a different story.
Perhaps American business should think twice about outsourcing more of our jobs to this backward nation. Get your act together, India, and maybe sometime in the future when you join the civilized world, we can talk about doing business.
Oooo….I am not a real man. I am just an animal that is a slave to its hormones. It’s her fault that she triggered my hormones. If I were a real man it would have been different, but I am no different than any other dog, pig or farm animal you might suggest……It’s her fault. She should be able to control my hormones better than I can.
We definitely should not be giving India over 130 million dollars a year in aid. Nor should we be outsourcing over there. A lot of medical transcriptionists in this country are out of a job or barely surviving on account of this type work being outsourced (most likely on account of greed because the Medical Transcription Service Organizations do not want to pay the American transcriptionists what they are worth). I'll just bet there are some good medical reports coming from that country back to our country. Medical transcription is hard work; it requires total concentration and a love of language plus a great typist. I know because I did that type work full time for over 10 years. I also did it part time for over 4 years. If any of our jobs (medical transcription or other types) are being sent to India, they should be brought back to America. If these people do not find these scum bags guilty and get them off the face of the earth -- we should totally reject this country until they change their way of treating females. After all, without a female, these male pigs would not be here.
Jessica, STFU with your progressive liberal diatribe. Dog and pony show at best.
This lawyers words and actions are despicable, and the GREAT majority of the public (left or right) would agree to that. Wanna know who probably would side with his defense? The holier than thou radical muslims that your "progressive movement" defends to the teeth in Dearborne, MI. They are already trying to bring shariah law into the court system and it is well known (yet kept taboo) that honor killings happen regularly.
Keep spewing your libtard horsesh!t.
What kinda bull@!$%# backwards logic are these guys coming up with. "Oh if she had just used the name of God, she wouldn't have been raped". Are you f*cking kidding me?? Did these guys go to the same human sexuality class that Todd Akin did? It's like manning the phone at a rape crises hotline and when a victim calls to report a rape the first thing you ask is "What were you wearing".
ORB 1943...nail it...LOL...
Typical from those cultures , where woman has the value of an object. I'm not sure but in some of those countries , in order to send to jail the rapist the female victim needs five male witness to testifier against the perpetrator. Since the UN was take over by Meddle East countries and Dictators there is no progress about woman rights.
LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOO
So... in this idiot's mind, it is OK to rape a woman as long as she looks like a whore??!?!
WOW... WATCH OUT KIM KARDASHIAN... NEVER, EVER GO TO INDIA.
This piece of manure should be executed along with the bastards that did this.
India: Backwards country, Primitive Culture... Useless.
will-2193211, does Rush calling Sandra Fluke a slut for testifying for birth control access before congress qualify?
Well said, Jessica. We often forget how recently our own culture has discriminated against women, the handicapped, people of color, etc. Things are better now but it was not that long ago that women could not own property or vote and career choices were limited to secretary, phone operator or housewife.
Earlier news said they were having trouble finding a lawyer in India that would take the defense case - and it shows - this lawyer is the bottom of the barrel. The victim's male friend who survived, his testimony ought to be key, surely the lot of them will hang.
Or, maybe the "gang" will just show up dead in their cells.
"Guilt is not one-sided," Indian spiritual leader Asaram Bapu, told followers earlier in the week, adding that if the woman had pleaded with her six attackers in God's name, and told them she was of the "weaker sex," they would have relented, Reuters reported."
"The lawyer's comments, which echoed those by some conservative religious and political figures, were likely to meet with more outrage from India’s urban middle class, which has spearheaded fierce protests against the government and police for their perceived failure to protect women from violence.'
If this is their thinking they have bigger problems than I originally thought. This is a hell hole. I don't think we should give them anymore aid.
According to Muslim Shari'a law, the husband who accuses a wife of infidelity must swear in god's name he is telling the truth, then either produce four witnesses (male or female) who will swear in God's name that they saw the act of penetration.
If he does not have the required witnesses the woman can refute the accusation by swearing to God three times that she is innocent of the charges. After that if either party wishes, a divorce can be granted and the amount of money and goods the man must give the divorced wife is settled there, or they can return to their home and continue to be man and wife.
If the man produces the required witnesses and the woman's oath of innocence is rejected (it is often but in few cases is accepted--I heard of one such testimony interrupted by an earthquake while the husband was speaking and it was interpreted by the religious elder as a sign from God that the man was swearing falsely) the religious elders can proscribe punishment for the either the man or woman, whoever was decreed to be lying, everything from ordering the innocent spouse to deny the lying spouse 'marital favors' for a set number of days, up to a beating..and there are strict laws about how the offender can be beaten, how many strokes they must be given, what climate/temperatures this is permissible to do it in,even the condition of the instrument used to hit the offender with and how they must be dressed.
Women, pay attention--what you see is what happens when men are allowed make all the rules!!!!
All of that being said, however--INDIA IS NOT MUSLIM. INDIA 'S NATIONAL RELIGION IS HINDU. The above law would not apply in a Hindu state.
Ah, the Catch-22 is that, in India, once a woman has been raped, she loses respect, apparently even if she dies. So no wonder he has never heard of a respectable woman who has been raped...
Jessica:
When I think of history and where it all got started in the early 1900s, I think of these people:
“The woman suffrage movement was led by old stock women,
especially Yankees and Quakers of English or German ancestry, whose families
had been in North America for generations. There were important ethnic
involvements as well by recent immigrants. Norwegian American women, based in
the rural upper Midwest, built their claims to an American identity on their
suffrage work. They felt that the progressive politics of Norway, which
included women's rights, provided a strong foundation for their demands for political
equality and inclusion in the U.S. They told their kinswomen they had a
cultural duty to promote women's rights, especially through the Scandinavian Woman's
Suffrage Association.”
It really did take a long time to change views and laws.
These are the people that started the movement.
Amanda, kinda weird you bring up Shari'a in a conversation about a Hindu state. But oh well.
I try to consider myself a peaceful person, but if I was related to the victim, I could kind of see myself beating this lawyer to death with my bare hands. Or lettering him survive barely, and then waiting for him to get out of traction and physical therapy, and then beating him also to death with bare hands again. Rinse and Repeat.
Even is an Hindu State they have a population of 156 millions of Muslims , half of the population of US.
However ,
Indian law, under section 375 of the criminal code, terms rape as penetration without consent. Courts have interpreted that to mean the penetration of a woman’s vagina by a penis.
Courts have thrown out attempts to allow for other kinds of rape and sexual assault to come under the definition.
Not too far from their Muslim brothers.
Thanks Zapper:
"One of the things stated was that the lady's attackers had managed to pull her intestines out. This must've been an attack of extreme violence to go so far as to "gut" someone. If, indeed, she was disrespectable, why not just kill her outright? Why torture, rape, mutilate and gut her?"
If India doesn't hang these men there is no hope for women there. These women should get the hell out of India or revolt. I'm sorry but this is so over the top I just can't stomach it. These monsters should be torn to pieces. They are a disease that shouldn't be allowed to grow.
I don't believe in hell, but if there was ever a few pieces of scum that deserved it, it would be these SOBs. I think drawing and quartering them would be ok, but we should make it more like 1/128 - ing... start with toes and fingers.
Brad - Does Bill Mayer calling Sarah Palin a cu*t count? O wait, he's a liberal, he's supposed to talk that way. That's why President Obama did not find it necessary to call Palin with an apology the way he did Fluke. It's OK for liberals to insult conservative women but TERRIBLE for Conservatives to insult feminist. What a bunch of hypocrites. Talk about a war on women!
Webster definition - Slut "a sexually promiscuous woman". I believe Sandra Fluke fits that description.
Will, if I call you a cu*t would it make you feel better?
Bill Mayer is a comedian. He cusses for every other word. He makes fun of everyone, it's his job.
Rush calling Fluke a slut because she went before congress to talk to all the white males who were trying to make decision for women about the other side of the coin is different. You morons take him seriously. Not the same.
Also, my wife and I use birth control. The majority of the country uses birth control. Many use it for health needs. It's a medical item. How in the f@#%$ did you assho!es pick that out as something so horrible that it shouldn't be covered by the health insurance that we all pay for. If I have to pay into insurance that gives your obese ass diabetes medication because you're too lazy to get off the couch and exercise, it better damn well pay for birth control so I can avoid contributing to overpopulation by bringing another kid into this crappy world.
"Guilt is not one-sided," Indian spiritual leader Asaram Bapu, told followers earlier in the week, adding that if the woman had pleaded with her six attackers in God's name, and told them she was of the "weaker sex," they would have relented, Reuters reported." Religion is the bane of human existence.
Travis - typical liberal response. You cannot discuss intelligently issues on which we may disagree so you digress to insults and name calling. For your information I am in top condition and could probably whip your whiny liberal candy ass standing on one leg so peace out my homey. LOL
BTW I happen to know Sandra Fluke. Do you? And if your wife is a sexually promiscuous woman no wonder you are so angry.
A little sensitive, are you, Will? I don't see where Travis called you a name; he asked a hypothetical question. And it was you who accused his wife of being sexually promiscuous because they use contraception.
And apparently you know Sandra Fluke and detest her. Maybe you willfully choose to forget she was testifying on the behalf of someone else, not herself.
Will - technically I would be considered a conservative Christian, in the fact that I follow the teachings of Christ. Unlike the "conservative Christians" like yourself who would rather rant and rave based upon nothing. I like that (in your response below) that you said I must believe in evolution therefore I do not read... so you're saying the more scientifically minded, research oriented individuals in this country read less than the people who think that humans put saddles on dinosaurs... right.....
So you know Sandra Fluke personally? Sounds like you're a terrible friend.
Considering that nearly every woman in the US uses some form on contraceptive, you obviously have no idea what you're talking about. Please crawl back down to you mother's basement and leave the rest of us in peace.
You're not intimidating, you're not powerful, and you do not garner respect. You are pathetic, and your ideas are without grounds.
Please consider the actual issues being discussed. Please stop living your life based upon Rush Limbaugh. Please stop giving humanity a bad name. Thanks!
This Defense attorney in India should experience a gang rape and then death.
It is a man's world in the 3rd World Countries, even rape; rape is common in India, so why would this case be any different?
My condolences to the Father of the Victim and his family--'They get it"---barbarians who protect one another, that is those wild animal men. Women are thought of as replaceable--they just need a "womb" to produce boys.
Travis, So you consider yourself a conservative Christian? With language like this and I quote;
"How in the f@#%$ did you assho!es pick that out as something so horrible that it shouldn't be covered by the health insurance that we all pay for. If I have to pay into insurance that gives your obese ass diabetes medication because you're too lazy to get off the couch and exercise, it better damn well pay for birth control so I can avoid contributing to overpopulation by bringing another kid into this crappy world",
maybe you had better reconsider.
Yes I do know Sandra Fluke and no I am not her Friend. And no I do not think my tax dollars should go to fund ANY type of birth control which is what the whole Fluke thing was about. TAX PAYER funded insurance for college students paying for birth control pills. Especially UNMARRIED college students who, (as a self professing conservative Christian you should agree), should not be having sex anyway.
If you READ my entire post, I was addressing redvirginia's comment about needing witnesses to an act of penetration.
I clarified for her the exact item of Sharia law she brought up, including requirements and penalties, then in my last sentence I informed her India was HINDU and so Muslim laws don't apply.
PLEASE go read my post again as well as redvirginia's original comment.
This is outrageous. Disgusting. There are no words to describe this lawyer and the "men" he is defending. Blame her because they have no self control, respect, or decency. And because of them, she is no longer around to defend herself. I can't imagine the pain her family is going through.
Severed - You need to read more carefully. I quote from Travis's post
"How in the f@#%$ did you assho!es pick that out as something so horrible that it shouldn't be covered by the health insurance that we all pay for. If I have to pay into insurance that gives your obese ass diabetes medication because you're too lazy to get off the couch and exercise".
And I did not call his wife anything. I made a hypothetical statement. He is the one who compared her to Sandra Fluke.
I guess this wasn't intended as a joke, but said in all seriousness?
Rapists and murderers everywhere look for the weaker and defenseless to commit their crime. Those victims are the ones they seek for their crimes of violence.
Anyway - back to the article, there is NO excuse for rape, period. I wonder if any of these men or their lawyer have daughters or sisters. They certainly ALL have mothers.
Blaming a woman for rape is as ridiculous as blaming a gun for murder. OR blaming a stupid video for a planned attack / assasination. O-O that's another can of worms.
Will,
You realize that your cussing precludes a holier-than-thou-attitude, correct? My issue with your attitude towards birth control is your raging need to control others and force them to conform to your set of beliefs. Jesus was the one who originally instituted separation of church and state. He said, My followers will be no part of this world, just as I am no part of this world. That statement was in response to when the Jews wanted to crown him king and have him rule. God would not associate himself with an imperfect human government, nor does the government have any role in trying to force religious beliefs upon their subjects. That being said, no where in the Bible, anywhere, does it ever state anything that would indicate birth control is bad (yes, they had condoms back then). That bulls!t was made up by the Catholic Church hundreds of years later as a means to control the masses and increase their numbers.
Will - once again, if the health insurance covers your medical needs, it should cover those of women as well. That would be why it's called "HEALTH INSURANCE". You start cherry-picking which kinds of medicine and treatments you want to disallow... boy that sure sounds like the death-panels you freaks were screaming "Obamacare" was going to cause... I quote your dumbass and your dumbass friends, "We don't want the Guvment' telling us what healthcare we can and cannot get". Jackass hypocrites!
Travis- I did not cuss, that was you. #2 - the government IS forcing religious beliefs on me when it uses my tax dollars to pay for any type of birth control. If an individual wants to purchase private health insurance that covers birth control so be it. I am talking about tax payer funded health insurance for college students. ESPECIALLY unmarried college students. There is a difference.
You need to study your Bible a little more carefully before you expound upon it. The Bible is very clear about having sex outside the confines of marriage. Now, if a husband and wife decide to use contraceptives as a way to control family size and you want your PRIVATE insurance to pay for it, that is your choice.
And I never said ""We don't want the Guvment' telling us what healthcare we can and cannot get" as you so eloquently state. Please, if you are going to quote me, make it legit.
insurance paying for Flukes birth control is wrong, that's not a medical issue. If BC is needed to reset a girls cycle, that's different. Getting preg is NOT a medical issue defined as a problem. No matter what the LIBS say.
You a holes are actually using this story to debate birth control???
Americans must remember, the people in 3rd World countries do not have rational thoughts when it comes to rape, or any other barbaric act. Americans should not think this as the typical rape in the US--
Indians are brainwashed from the time of birth, the men---the women are submissive, and are probably glad just to be alive. Most women in these countries are "beaten repeatedly" when they make a mistake, or The Pig of a husband, boyfriend thinks they have done wrong. Relate all this thinking to the KORAN--am not sure that Indians refer to some writings of their own---
India has a Caste System. The highest one being those of the wealthy and the educated. The rest are so poor that it is much like the typical lives of Middle Eastern people--barbaric--cruel, and are taught to shove their women around--or kill them--no value of life there either. Illiterate, nomads, and starving. No jobs, no purpose in life. Rape is common, but this is an unusual father who brought this out of the closet--He could be killed, too.
Welcome to Newsvine!
The idiots were debating gun control over on the same sex marriage topic earlier. Some people will use any and all topics to spout their rhetoric. Best you can do is point and laugh at their desperation.
That's an interesting observation, as I read a few days ago that the court find not a single attorney anywhere that would take their case. I believe this one is one is the equivalent of one of our Supreme Court justices or Federal Court justices who had to step down in order to take the case.
It could be that you are correct, and his statement is deliberately outrageous to make even the criminal element see that this type of thing cannot be condoned any more, especially if India is to attract foreign investment and business.
At any rate, this attorney is not "just" an attorney, and I believe he has an ulterior motive in making this statement.
Proud to be an American!!
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/17/sports/high-school-football-rape-case-unfolds-online-and-divides-steubenville-ohio.html
http://abcnews.go.com/US/gang-rape-charges-18-men-sparks-racial-tensions/story?id=13095476
http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/girl-15-gang-raped-class-suit-article-1.123872
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/03/24/10841028-9-charged-in-alleged-gang-rape-of-14-year-old-girl-at-party-in-st-paul-minn?lite
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Richmond_High_School_gang_rape
enough examples? how about statistics?
US NATIONAL RAPE/SEXUAL ASSAULT STATISTICS
According to a study conducted by the US National Victim Center, 1.3 women (age 18 and over) in the United States are forcibly raped each minute. That translates to 78 an hour, 1,871 per day, or 683,000 per year. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, nearly 6 out of 10 rape/sexual assault incidents are reported by victims to have occurred in their own home or at the home of a friend, relative, or neighbor.51% of the sexual assault cases studied in the Women’s Safety Project survey were committed against young women between 16 and 21 years old.According to the U.S. Department of Justice, Only 16% of rapes are ever reported to the police. In a survey of victims who did not report rape or attempted rape to the police, the following was found as to why no report was made: 43% thought nothing could be done, 27% felt it was a private matter, 12% were afraid of police response, and 12% felt it was not important enough.13.3% of college women indicated that they had been forced to have sex in a dating situation.In a national survey 27.7% of college women reported a sexual experience since the age of fourteen that met the legal definition of rape or attempted rape, and 7.7% of college men reported perpetrating aggressive behavior which met the legal definition of rape.Among developmentally disabled adults, as many as 83% of the females and 32% of the males are the victims of sexual assault.16% of male students surveyed by the Ms. Foundation who had committed rape, and 10% of those who attempted a rape, took part in episodes involving multiple perpetrators.Women with disabilities are raped and abused at a rate at least twice that of the general population of women.
Chris from Yucaipa,
And your one of the worst when it comes to this. Didnt you just bring up Akin earlier? But that must be ok right Chris.
A lawyer's job is to defend his clients no matter what. Its probably the only possible defense these guys have. So saying we should kill the lawyer is a bit extreme. Yeah, lets kill people who dont agree with us. That couldnt possibly be used in the wrong way. And dont worry, even if the three guys somehow manage to get off because there were misogynists on the jury, I dont think they will last too long with how everyone in the country is calling for their blood.
Unbelievable! He feels this young woman was equally guilty in her own rape and murder just because she wouldn't allow them to mount? I suspect some toy store in India had a sale on lawyer's graduation certificates and he picked up a few!
Tghe lawyer made a good argument..... to be hanged along side of the rapists, what plantet do these religious fundamentalists come from? Really, only with God can rape and murder be justified.
Defense lawyers are slime, no matter the country in which they live. This s.o.b. should, at the very least, lose his bar license for blaming the female victim. However, a more fitting punishment would be to tie him up in the town square and let the women to hack him to death with machetes.
......and they should be exceptionally dull so it would take much longer and inflict the maximum amount of pain.
What about rusty metal sporks? I'm thinking death by rusty metal spork would be more appropriate.
I think the defense lawyer sounds like Republican politician, like that guy Akins.
Just because this defense lawyer is making ridiculous statements, it does not mean that he will win the case.
The prosecutors will present their case, DNA, and witnesses.
The criminals will probably be convicted and hanged.
If the defense lawyer does not even present a case, then a conviction could be overturned upon appeal.
I can't even wrap my mind around what this slime-ball (thinking of much worse name but would be a big no-no on here) is saying. NO woman (whether someone thinks she is a respected lady or not) deserves to be raped and violated like this poor young woman was. I knew that they didn't treat woman with respect in India but I didn't realize they were this bad. I think that this lawyer needs to be tried just next to the pigs who did this to this young lady. I feel so bad for her family to have to been subjected to this disgust while trying to heal from her passing. And to "stmiller" this is not the proper time for sick humor like that, please respect the dead even if her own people can't.
How can you argue with logic like that?
Why, isn't he right, after all? Because respectable women don't ride the bus, of all things! Surely, she was asking for it because she chose public transportation! I suspect the next accusation will be that the man with her was her pimp and they were looking for business. Yea, the whole medical school thing was just a ruse to get money from prostitution, right, Sharma?
I suspect Rush Limbaugh will be taking up this story on his show talking about those poor men are lucky they dont live in America, because the feminazi's would destroy their lives.
whenever I hear that "respectable women" crap, my thought are, aren't you also saying that the men in your culture are barely more than animals that can't controll themselves? My dog is better behaved than that.
Jessica - You obviously have never listened to Rush's show because if you had you would know the deffinition of a feminazi. In case you are interested in the facts, here is what he said,
"A feminazi is a woman to whom the most important thing in life is seeing to it that as many abortions as possible are performed. Their unspoken reasoning is quite simple. Abortion is the single greatest avenue for militant women to exercise their quest for power and advance their belief that men aren't necessary. They don't need men in order to be happy. They certainly don't want males to be able to exercise any control over them. Abortion is the ultimate symbol of women's emancipation from the power and influence of men. With men being precluded from the ultimate decision-making process regarding the future of life in the womb, they are reduced to their proper, inferior role. Nothing matters but me, says the feminazi. My concerns prevail over all else. The fetus doesn't matter, it's an unviable tissue mass.
Feminazis have adopted abortion as a kind of sacrament for their religion/politics of alienation and bitterness". [The Way Things Ought to Be, Rush Limbaugh, pages 194-195]
Ugh, after reading that excerpt from Rush, I think I threw up a little. That POS can choke on syphillitic elephant testicles.
Rush called Hilary Clinton a feminazi WAY back in the day, as in during the Clinton Admin. It was the first, and last, time I listened to that moron's program. He's made quite a name for himself, but after his little incident over the birth control issue last year, he lost so many sponsors it had to hurt. (good)
Before his screwup, he was pulling down in the neighborhood of $35 million a year... or maybe that was the other dumb@ss Beck.
Rush will do ANYTHING, say anything, he is a media whore - and he gets paid big bucks. No wonder faux news continues with their drivel - there's money to be made.
Rush is still #1 so it must not have hurt him too much. The book that this excerpt is taken from was published around 1992 so that fits with the Clinton era. And Hillary fits the description.
More of the excerpt from the1992 book The Way Things Ought to Be "I prefer to call the most obnoxious feminists what they really are: feminazis. Tom Hazlett, a good friend who is an esteemed and highly regarded professor of economics at the University of California at Davis, coined the term to describe any female who is intolerant of any point of view that challenges militant feminism. I often use it to describe women who are obsessed with perpetuating a modern-day holocaust: abortion. There are 1.5 million abortions a year, and some feminists almost seem to celebrate that figure. There are not many of them, but they deserve to be called feminazis".
Yes but just because Rush insists on gargling jizz into a radio microphone every morning does not seem to be a good enough excuse to justify his reasoning.
Also, by his own definition, seeing as Hillary did not have an abortion and has children, he's a lying sack of sh@% hypocrite.
He's a drug addicted, holier than thou fat piece of regurgitated dog vomit that has somehow been allowed to blather into the ears of the weaker-minded retards of this country for decades. Howard Stern is less offensive, and he's desperately trying to be offensive. Excusing Rush (and reading his damn books) disqualifies you from weighing in with a opinion deserving consideration.
Travis - says you. But then again, you think you evolved from a monkey so reading books is probably not your strong point. And if you ever took the time to read or listen to what Rush says instead of basing your biased, bigoted opinions on what you hear from your leftist friends you might actually add a speck of validity to your argument. Your opinion that sexist pig Howard Stern is less offensive proves your warped mindset.
Rush promised to leave the country if Obama got elected the first time. When will he make good on his word? I'm waiting with excited anticipation. We need no sexist pigs here. Sounds like India would be a good fit for good old Rush.
LIBERAL DICTIONARY
Hate = standing up for Christian values.
Love = defending diversity unless that diversity happens to be Christianity.
Women’s rights = killing innocent babies 180movie.com
Charity = take from the productive and make dependants of the non-productive.
Balanced budget = essential for families, does not apply to government.
Truth = whatever you want it to be
Absolute truth = non-existent
Freedom of speech = as long as it is “politically correct”
Freedom of religion = unless it’s Christianity
God = man
HYPOCRITE = anyone who disagrees with us
bigot = anyone who disagrees with us
idiot = anyone who disagrees with us
Hate group = anyone who works to strengthen traditional families
Preaching hate = openly expressing a view contrary to ours.
Sexist Pig = anyone who does not buy into the radical feminist agenda and says so.
BTW - Howard Stern and Bill Maher. Now THERE are a couple of sexist pigs.
Please consider that as long as women are not protected under the law, they have to protect themselves in any way they can. They are not paid equally, and truthfully are not represented by the Constitution. They are given a raw deal from birth. If a woman doesn't want to have a kid, it is likely that the many social injustices she has suffered she would not wish on another person.
Fix the Constitution. Allow women to stand up for themselves and be the force they can be. Pay women a fair wage. Make the punishment for rape be so egregious that no guy dares it. See how many fewer abortions ensue.
Going after the symptom only compounds the problem.
It does make you want to wring is disgusting little neck.
"FacePalm".....
This sorry excuse for a man and all that have his mentality make me want to puke! These six men sexually assault one woman and this guy says all she would have had to say is "In God's name, please stop... I am the weaker sex" and this would not have happened??!!! That is BEYOND absurd! I am sure this woman was begging and pleading for her life!!! Don't the men in India KNOW that the woman is the weaker sex? She has to "tell" them??? Is there really a population of men who are that STUPID??!!!
The only way to wake up the "men" in this country is to rape them. They believe in an eye for an eye then so be it.
This is exactly the way we used to treat rape victims in the US. Then we began passing laws that disallowed attacking the victim for being a victim. It's gotten a lot better, but there are still plenty of men in this country who believe "she was asking for it" is a good excuse and a good defense.
When I was raising my kids, they were taught that saying, "He/she made me do it," was the worst and most inexcusable defense they could mount. Then they were in even more trouble for not owning their own choices. I still bristle when I hear people use that as an excuse for bad behavior. In this case, since when is murder EVER justified?
Diane, I hope you don't mean all men, because most of us are not like that. It is the few that give the many a bad name.
Frankly, I believe child molesters should be executed, and rapists should have their genitals removed before spending at least 15 years in prison without parole, and with full make-up permanently tattooed on their face and with breast implants as well. Any violence used in the rape should be seperate charges as well, and should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, and also without possibility of parole.
*
this guy is following the mainstream thought process of India, women are less than people and should know their place, and that's why these asshats are gonna walk. unbelievable as it may seem. their religious leaders will cover for them with yet another outrageous excuse. the lawyer and the murderers need to all dangle at the end of a rope. as for women thinking you have it bad here......really????????????
Rocky - most men in this country respect women, and dont rape them. Most American men - and when I say most I mean way up there 99% plus, are repelled by this type of thing. Most American men would be protective of a woman being assaulted - they would come to her aid in some way. Most men in AMerica dont believe a woman asks to be raped.
American Men are mostly gentlemen who treat women the way women should be treated - with dignity and repsect. ANd ladies I want to remind you that if a man behaves to you like a gentleman - holds a door, pulls out your chair (not when you are sitting in it) etc. it would be nice to thank him. In fact I think I am going to thank the men in my life today for being the gentlemen that they are.
Women may be weaker when it comes to the physical body, but mentally, emotionally, and socially they are light years ahead of men.
well SR, that depends on the education and upbringing..................not all women are all that bright...my point? nancy pelosi.............nuff said.
Proud to be an American!!
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/17/sports/high-school-football-rape-case-unfolds-online-and-divides-steubenville-ohio.html
http://abcnews.go.com/US/gang-rape-charges-18-men-sparks-racial-tensions/story?id=13095476
http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/girl-15-gang-raped-class-suit-article-1.123872
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/03/24/10841028-9-charged-in-alleged-gang-rape-of-14-year-old-girl-at-party-in-st-paul-minn?lite
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Richmond_High_School_gang_rape
enough examples? how about statistics?
US NATIONAL RAPE/SEXUAL ASSAULT STATISTICS
According to a study conducted by the US National Victim Center, 1.3 women (age 18 and over) in the United States are forcibly raped each minute. That translates to 78 an hour, 1,871 per day, or 683,000 per year. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, nearly 6 out of 10 rape/sexual assault incidents are reported by victims to have occurred in their own home or at the home of a friend, relative, or neighbor.51% of the sexual assault cases studied in the Women’s Safety Project survey were committed against young women between 16 and 21 years old.According to the U.S. Department of Justice, Only 16% of rapes are ever reported to the police. In a survey of victims who did not report rape or attempted rape to the police, the following was found as to why no report was made: 43% thought nothing could be done, 27% felt it was a private matter, 12% were afraid of police response, and 12% felt it was not important enough.13.3% of college women indicated that they had been forced to have sex in a dating situation.In a national survey 27.7% of college women reported a sexual experience since the age of fourteen that met the legal definition of rape or attempted rape, and 7.7% of college men reported perpetrating aggressive behavior which met the legal definition of rape.Among developmentally disabled adults, as many as 83% of the females and 32% of the males are the victims of sexual assault.1Women with disabilities are raped and abused at a rate at least twice that of the general population of women.
The whole "she made me do it" excuse comes directly from Genesis!
Color me thoroughly unsurprised. I'm fond of India as a culture, but it is clearly no exception to the universal presence of asshats in every society, nor of the temptation to pay far more attention to their ravings than they deserve. This guy should have lost his legal credentials the instant he made a claim this spectacularly outrageous and wrong, but of course all we ever care about is how much you paid for a nice-looking suit, not about whether you actually have two functioning brain cells to rub together.
The only thing that I like about the country of India is their version of a scratch off lottery ticket. If you scratch one and one of the red dots matches the red dot on your wife's forehead you win a 7-11 in America.
I thought that was the start button ?
I also heard it was from their husband aggressively poking their forehead as they demand to know how come they are so ugly.
Sorry ladies, I still can't resist a good joke. Now cut off that attorneys balls and make him eat them.
WHAT !!!
you're kidding ..
And we thought the lawyers here in America were motherless scumbags...
With all the crazed snipers, shooters and serial killers in the world why couldn't there be just one that targets lawyers...
Is it true that 90% of lawyers are giving the other 10% a bad name ?
That is so wrong....It's actually 1%...Lol
When a person assists a criminal in breaking the law before the criminal gets arrested, we call him an accomplice. When a person assists a criminal in breaking the law after the criminal gets arrested, we call him a defense lawyer.
While I love a good attorney joke as much as the rest of you, on a serious note I would suggest all you defense attorney haters read about John Adams (founding father and 3rd president) he SUCCESSFULLY DEFENDED the british troops accused of murder in the Boston Massacre reading the reasoning he used to decide to defend them - and at presonal risk - is an interesting tale of how the American justice system was founded.
Also - lets not let prosecutors off - if they didn't pleas bargain so much there might be more convictions.
Not related to this topic, but if you honestly believe that then why bother with trial? A simple arrest should be evidence enough of guilt, right? Who needs a jury trial?
I hope you remember that if you're ever arrested and need a lawyer.
Hollykb
John Adams was an anomaly, as was Abraham Lincoln: an ethical lawyer.
Is this guy a friend of Todd 'legitimate rape' Akins?
Or, maybe it's 'What God intended' Murdock!
Damn, they sound an awful lot like Conservative, Christian Republicans here in the US. You can find all kinds of comments from christian republicans blaming women for getting raped here. Things like she wore the wrong clothes or shouldn't be without a man to protect her. :p
Men in general are misogynistic pigs all over the world.
As Republicans know, if it’s a legitimate rape the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.
Sandy,Missouri - you use the word "Christian" loosely. Just because someone calls themselves Christians, doesn't make it so - but some people, like yourself, sure do like to reinforce that lie. No real Christian would do or say anything that Christ Himself would not do or say. The Conservative Republicans you cite are fake Christians - if you knew Christ, you already know that.
Wow. Just wow.
This is why the majority of women agree with the principles of feminism but specifically AVOID labelling themselves as feminists. I'm referring to the 1999 Gallup poll. It really doesn't matter whether you consider yourself a feminist here, since some of the most vocal proponents of women's rights in recent decades have been pretty open about their misandry. All that matters is that when you say something like "all men are pigs," people want to distance themselves from you, and the rest of your views, no matter how right you might be on other matters.
I think what you *meant* to say is that SOME men are awful, cruel, bigoted, sexist, and sadistic creatures, which is something I wish weren't so true, but have to agree with. To put all, or just most men in the "generally evil" category can alienate, if not offend, those who would otherwise agree with what you're saying.
Is that why over 99% of prison inmates identify themselves as Democrats. They are the killers, the rapists, the thieves, the drug dealers, the gang members, the child molesters, the drunk drivers. What a fine bunch Democrats have in their company.
Go to a womens prison, and it is much the same scenario with a few bonuses that have killed their own kids and such. Wonderful Sandy, thanks for lumping us all into one group like the brainless slob you likely are. Your generalized man hating is unwarranted and plain old wrong.
What nonsense. Yes she should have said that men who think like the Lawyer are pigs, but why this big rant on democrats?
Sandy is correct, 99% of rapist are men. The military "good ol' boy" club" uses this type of defense all the time when women are raped in the military...they asked for it!!! The use of date-rape drugs is prevalent, as is the refusal by superiors to believe rape charges. One woman stationed at an isolated base in Alaska couldn’t tell anyone about multiple rape attacks because all outside calls were routed through a base operator who listened in. Several other women were themselves charged with adultery because their rapists were married. An accomplished young Marine with a post at the prestigious Marine Corps Barracks in Washington was horrified to watch her rapist go unpunished while she was charged with conduct-unbecoming and public intoxication. The Department of Defense estimates roughly 19,000 sexual assaults occur each year within the military services, and just a fraction of those—around 3,100 in 2010—are reported. Of those rapes that are brought to the military’s attention, only 17% are ever prosecuted and only 6% of troops who commit rape ever spend any time in jail.
Gee, you really can't be that colossally stupid, can you Sandy? Oh, excuse me--apparently you can. And the really disturbing thing is you apparently have company. Be sure and share your views with your father, brothers, husband, sons, boss, and every male you know. I'm sure they'll view you as a rational, reasoned person instead of a male-bashing hysteric. Then again, maybe not.
1Citizen - Said very well, more people should already know that. But we live in that kind of society, were your wrong if they don't want to hear it. So sad!! Truth and education don't seem to mix much anymore.
Noah - you're very right, not all men are pigs.
But I think you're dead wrong about why most women dont say they are feminists, even if they clearly are.
It's because they dont want to be called Feminazi's, a term most popular coined by Conservatives, like Rush Limbaugh - and repeated, very often on these boards, by regular ol conservatives who like to pretend they don't drag their knuckles neanderthal style like these crazy Indians in this article.
I'm a Feminist, but I dont think all men are pigs, I dont hate all men - but the minute I say I am one, out of the woodwork crawls every crazy conservative telling me im nothing but a man-hating feminazi.
And you know, when THAT happens...it makes it really hard to keep telling myself most men dont suck at life, arent pigs, and are really awesome people...because I rarely see it from the conservative side of the aisle.
Rocky Rhode - STRAIGHT UP BULL. Im so sick of this partisan mentally unbalanced bs...take it somewhere else, no one is buying your crap here.
He sounds like so many of the far right Republicans right here in the USA.
Jessica,
You see what you want to see. Keep spewing libtard diatribe, it suits you so well. He sounds more like the radical muslims (the type in Dearborne, MI) that affiliate themselves with the democratic party who gladly defends them to the teeth in return.
You hate republicans OH SO MUCH yet you defend the same people, in our backyards, who allow honor killings and all the other cruel things they do to women.
Pathetic and loaded with irony.
Next thing they will probably say: "If she hadn't been wearing the clothes she was wearing, it wouldn't have happened." It doesn't matter what type of clothing a woman is wearing at the time, if the woman says no, IT MEANS NO, period! Men have no right to violate that no. Once she says no, the activity should stop. The dangerous myth of "She didn't say no, she must have wanted it." needs to stop. Just because she didn't say no at the start, doesn't mean she can't say no at some other point. Since when do we live in caveman times when a man takes a woman back to his cave by her hair? we live in a society that needs to stop saying "When you say no, that makes you weak" If anything, it makes you stronger.
Gee Alchemy, you have a real, um, direct beef, on liberals - are you sure you aren't of the same mind as them there conservative mooslims up there in MI? Oh, the irony. Ironic - unless you do not realize that they are uber religious and political conservatives - if you don't know, it's just stupidity rather than irony.
If the subject of feminism comes up, I don't say "I am a feminist", I say I am "for women's rights" - and then give historical examples of before and after. When my grandmother was born, in 1916, they had not yet had suffrage for women - it took time to develop an mindset of equality, and in the US it is a work in progress. I would not live anywhere else.
Happytimes... yeah ok, cool story bro.
I'm a realist and more of a libertarian. I have ALOT of beef with liberals and just as many problems with the radical right as well.
Nice generalization though. I thought progressives were above that? I am perfectly aware of the mindset and attitudes of the muslim culture, and many other cultures. Progressives cry out in numbers against everybody remotely affiliated with any conservative belief yet protect the precious "mooslims" right to freedom of religion!? Ironic, yes. The only stupidity I see is your analysis of my comment.
Sandy~
As a woman, I take offence at your blanket label of men ALL being misogynistic pieces of @!$%#. I'm not saying that your assertion in this case particular is incorrect (I agree with you), but to pigeon hole an entire gender like that is just wrong. Put the shoe on the other foot and you'd be all kinds of up in arms.
On another note, I think it'd be lovely if the lower than life scums that raped/killed this poor woman and beat her companion, along with this lawyer be placed in general population in an American prision. I'd buy tickets to that severe beat down.
Sandy, Missouri - You were doing fine with an opinion, whether people would agree with you or not, until you decided to insult and bash all men in all the world. That is just pathetic. Get some therapy.
1Citizen, Noah R, and Agdoc 69 made some very good comments. It is women like Sandy who make some men hate women.
Sandy,
That's something a misandrist would say. I'd prefer you judge me as fellow human being, if you feel the need to judge me at all. That said, After reading the statements of the lawyer and the comments here, I'd say we've all got a long way to go as species. Most people here object to what this man said, but most of the dialogue here only serves to divide people. It's just inflammatory and doesn't serve a purpose. There is no "win" here.
These men (and I use the term loosely) not only raped the woman but murdered her. Mr. Sharma you are filth. God in any form would not approve of senseless murder. I volunteered in rape crisis and have seen many "respected" women raped. You repulse me.
Well I think Mr Sharma is incredibly rude for blaming that lovely lady and her partner!!!! I don't think bringing in and legalizing chemical castration is the answer. Men who are capable or committing such crimes will only re offend and others will continue to follow in their paths if the hanging penalty is not brought in. Its either that or have a remote Island with a big as prison lock them up and throw away the key and definitely no privileges allowed, or they can shack up with a whole lot of wild animals that wouldn't hesitate to have these perpetrators for breakfast, lunch or dinner. You know the saying a life for a life, at least they will experience what it feels like to be a victim hunted down, and die in pain!!!!
See below
There is only sense and these rapists and lawyer are senseless. Jail the senseless!
Really? Yes, in America, we have women wearing provocative clothes, come hither heels and tramp stamps. It doesn't ALLOW, in any sense of the word, rape, or for that matter, pinching a butt!
How can a country that wants to be taken seriously on the world stage, have such negative policies towards women? It's embarrassing.
YES - women in America ASK for it - they DO - but we at least hopefully don't DO it - and we certainly don't have an attorney saying it is their fault on the rare occasions when it happens. Don't mistake what I say when I say that they ask for it - they like to be sexy and desirable - it isn't wrong.
A 6 man gangbang..in a public bus...with an unwilling person...that died - not from injuries related to a penis - but from a PIPE that was used. Yeah...it was her fault - she wanted that.
In America - even though it would be wrong of a woman to do this - if she were on a bus - naked - spread eagled - and ONE man put a HAND uninvited - it's sexual assault. Yep - she was "asking for it" - but - didn't condone it.
I bet your knuckles bleed when you walk...
Is that saying..what.. neanderthal? Maybe..you could be more obscure....idiot.
Just because your mother and daughter charge all the homeless men $5.00 for a headjob in the alley behind the 7-11, would they be asking for it if one of those homeless men wanted more ? If your whore wife happens to swallow every mans giz and suddenly spits out from another does that mean she would deserve to be attacked ? Of course not. She may want to lower her price though as I have seen what she looks like and it's not attractive. Maybe that's why she can only offer BJ's. Hahahahahaa
Nice try troll. You are an idiot. And..how...could my mother and daughter be successful charging 5.00 when you only charge 2?
Not that I a support what Drac is saying but what I understand here (under all the other dumb comments) is that regardless of what a woman wears - whether it be "slutty" or "respectable" - no man has a right to force themselves on her. Unwanted sexual advances are rape regardless of what the woman is wearing. In this case, it should be 2 cases of assault and one case of murder NOT RAPE. A gang rape (using their penis) is one thing - still most definitely not right - but to use a freaking pipe to the point where you rupture a person's inner body parts is grotesque and beyond reasoning. I can't believe that these are the kinds of people that this poor excuse of a lawyer wants to release back into his society? And, if they are released under this type of defense, their justice system is only telling them that what they did is ok to do to ANY woman who is on a bus or out in public because they are asking for it - REGARDLESS of what they are wearing.
Well - all I am saying is simple - it doesn't matter what you wear - and yes, women in America tend to wear some provocative clothing - it doesn't mean you can do as you like. Yes, maybe they could dress a little more conservatively - but regardless, it isn't a green light to advances.
YES - they ask for it - not as in rape - but as in attention - that's all I am saying. The way some ladies dress would be the same as a man wearing a banana hammock and nothing else. There is an assumption made as to how a person is dressed - if you show the goods..well....
Again though - showing the goods does not mean, in any way, shape, or form, that a person should be groped or any other unwanted advances. Showing the goods...and nothing else - is known as a cocktease (just kidding!!!) - lighten up!!!!
I have the utmost respect for women - and this type of story is far too common and very sickening.
And yet you don't respect their right to wear what they want.
Draconian - so what you are saying is that a woman who wears sexy clothing, is "asking for it" but not "condoning it"...
in the same way that a person who wears really expensive clothing is ASKING TO GET ROBBED, but not condoning it?
Today im wearing a sweater and jeans, im wondering what my clothing choices suggest im "asking for"...? perhaps you can let me know?
Grandpa
I think what he is talking about IS a matter of respect. Yes woman should be able to wear whatever they want. But in this country there is a perception that wearing extremely reveling cloths is wrong. Not saying this is my opinion but it IS society's opinion. Cris Rock said it best when he stated that while wearing sleazy cloths does not make you a whore you ARE wearing a whore's uniform. Of course this has nothing to do with this girl in India or any woman that was raped in this country,no means no is something I believe in. I just think you were attacking the wrong person.
I guess that's why rape victims range in age from tiny babies to ancient great-great-grandmothers. (sarc)
Rape is about power, dominance, anger, violence. It has nothing to do with sex.
Jessica, AGAIN, keep spewing your idiotic horsesh!t. You are the epitome of ignorant feminism, not to be confused with feminists who live on earth and have the best interest of female equality in mind.
Walking through certain places at certain times dressed in uber expensive clothes is, yes infact, basically BEGGING to get robbed. Does he condone it? NO. Is that person making themselves an easy target, yeah kind of.
Your sweater and jeans are your way of asking for somebody to love and desire you the way they would a real woman. For them to give you a reason to not look like a busted slob and try taking a shower and feeling beautiful. No self respecting woman (feminist or not) could say and believe the things you do and be happy with who she is. Your antics are a desperate cry for attention and intervention. Whatever terrible thing some douchebage male did to you, i am genuinely sorry. Now get over it.
Alc - boo hoo - YOU get over it. Or does only you - get an opinion? Sheesh.
DrAlchemy, I must have missed the insane tirade of Jessica, because all I read was that she said saying a women is "asking for it" is like saying someone who has nice things is "asking to be robbed". She didn't elaborate much beyond that, so allow me (a male)
To the couple of dumbasses above who tell racists jokes, immediately followed by saying, I'm not a racist, some of my best friends are black, let me say this clearly:
A
Woman
is
NEVER
asking
to
be
raped.
You jackasses saying that they're inviting sexual assault by their clothing are cut from the same cloth as this @!$%# lawyer. You're blaming the victim, and excusing the monster who does the assault.
You are pieces of dogsh!t that need to be scraped from the bottom of the shoe of society. By your logic, you're "begging" to get shot by the people who are sick of these antiquated misogynistic ideals. Jessica said nothing offensive, and you go ranting against "ignorant feminism". Just know that we will be much happier when you and your ilk have passed away and leave the rest of this earth with more reasoned minds.
Your f@#tard reasoning of "asking for it, but not condoning it" is literally the weakest bullsh!t I've seen in years.
Travis, cool story bro. Did happy times call you in for support? I personally love your rant against other people's rants.
PS I never said a woman is asking for it by dressing sleezy or sexy or WTF you would prefer to call it. I never said it was right either. Are you pig headed enough to believe it doesn't happen anyways? That it is wiser to look rich walking through east LA at midnight than being dressed in something inconspicuous?
Take your ridiculous name calling and dimwitted insults and shove them up your @ss!
For The Gander, you are suspended for a day for violating rule # 1 of the Code of Honor.
Not good.
Draconian, don't respond like this to a personal attacks. Ignore and report please.
DrAlchemy, you are also suspended for a day. See above.
When we see a news story like this we tend to try to rationalize the nature of the story in western terms. That is a huge mistake that needs to be realized. Even in India, there is a diverse population that is heavily influenced by Islam. Go to the Indian news sites to read how this type of physical assaults take place all the time and the constant excuse is that these women ask to be assaulted because they are "loose" women by the standards set by Islam and the Koran. The society in India is a very dangerous place for women with western influence.the only safety within Islam is to conform. Resist and die or conform.
The thing we do not seem to realize is that a "Conservative" politician there is Islamic and very serious about abiding by these Muslim laws. We think of a conservative as a Jerry Falwell and the Debunk Moral Majority. Our Democracy protected us from their power struggle of the 70s and 80s, but They never murdered politicians or sinners. We see on the Internet where people are having their hands cut off, beheaded, or stoned to death as per Koran laws. The Majority of the people over there are illiterate and get extreme when God's Work is to be done.
Historically their Koran is derived from the Hebrew Writtings and what we know as the Old Testament. According to their Koran The writings alwys belonged and was intended for Muslims. They Call Jesus a prophet and say it is blathmeny to call him The son of allah(God).
The things we see today is a prelude to things to come should Islam ever reach a level of power of the Ottoman Empire. Ask the Turks (Ottoman) how it feels to try to remove the Islamic influence once it is permeated into a society.
Lazarus
India is a secular democracy. Indian law is based on English law.
You are confused.
You may be thinking of Saudi Arabia.
Proud to be an American!!
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/17/sports/high-school-football-rape-case-unfolds-online-and-divides-steubenville-ohio.html
http://abcnews.go.com/US/gang-rape-charges-18-men-sparks-racial-tensions/story?id=13095476
http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/girl-15-gang-raped-class-suit-article-1.123872
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/03/24/10841028-9-charged-in-alleged-gang-rape-of-14-year-old-girl-at-party-in-st-paul-minn?lite
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Richmond_High_School_gang_rape
enough examples? how about statistics?
US NATIONAL RAPE/SEXUAL ASSAULT STATISTICS
According to a study conducted by the US National Victim Center, 1.3 women (age 18 and over) in the United States are forcibly raped each minute. That translates to 78 an hour, 1,871 per day, or 683,000 per year. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, nearly 6 out of 10 rape/sexual assault incidents are reported by victims to have occurred in their own home or at the home of a friend, relative, or neighbor.51% of the sexual assault cases studied in the Women’s Safety Project survey were committed against young women between 16 and 21 years old.According to the U.S. Department of Justice, Only 16% of rapes are ever reported to the police. In a survey of victims who did not report rape or attempted rape to the police, the following was found as to why no report was made: 43% thought nothing could be done, 27% felt it was a private matter, 12% were afraid of police response, and 12% felt it was not important enough.13.3% of college women indicated that they had been forced to have sex in a dating situation.In a national survey 27.7% of college women reported a sexual experience since the age of fourteen that met the legal definition of rape or attempted rape, and 7.7% of college men reported perpetrating aggressive behavior which met the legal definition of rape.Among developmentally disabled adults, as many as 83% of the females and 32% of the males are the victims of sexual assault.16% of male students surveyed by the Ms. Foundation who had committed rape, and 10% of those who attempted a rape, took part in episodes involving multiple perpetrators. Women with disabilities are raped and abused at a rate at least twice that of the general population of women.
Let me get this straight--a woman who fails to use the right lingo to convince a slimeball or group of such to not please rape, torture, and murder her on the public streets is totally guilty and the slimeballs should be set free due to her failure to properly plead for mercy. How could we be so stupid as to blame these poor perpetrators then--set them free at once!
Don't we in the US give our tax dollars to this country? We need to stop. Any country that condones rape, and India definitely feels it is their right to rape women for whatever sick reason they come up with, should be banned from the UN, they should not be allowed to enter this country, unless it is a female looking for asylum and we HAVE to cut all financial ties with them. The only thing people understand is the almighty dollar before they'll do anything about sick behavior that they condone. And we send a lot of our dollars to this country!!!
I agree, however, India is far from alone in it's abuse of women. It's sickening.
Saudi Arabia believes that women need to wear an Abaya (ghost outfit) because it will lessen the temptations of men. So...make a woman wear a head to toe outfit - in that heat - because MEN can't control their urges...sure thing...
All companies who have outsourced their businesses, like call centres, should stop the practice immediately.
India and China are going to be global nightmares for generations to come, until recently, totally impoverished but now suddenly both have affluent sectors. Give a poor person a ton of money and most of them will immediately start to behave stupidly.
How could those 3 countries have been admitted to high-level international bodies - Security council, nuclear nations, and respected for their opinions? Obviously because they were seen as huge profit markets. No other reason possible. Money money money.
90% OF THESE THIRD WORLD COUNTRY'S THAT WE SEND MONEY TO BELIEVE THE SAME WAY.
In their culture woman are property to do with as they please. They sell their daughters to older men. They force their wife's to wear certain cloths,cover their face's,stay in the home unless accompanied by an adult male of the family ect. While we don't believe in their culture they also don't believe in ours. What we need to do is stop sending money to other country's period
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/17/sports/high-school-football-rape-case-unfolds-online-and-divides-steubenville-ohio.html
http://abcnews.go.com/US/gang-rape-charges-18-men-sparks-racial-tensions/story?id=13095476
http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/girl-15-gang-raped-class-suit-article-1.123872
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/03/24/10841028-9-charged-in-alleged-gang-rape-of-14-year-old-girl-at-party-in-st-paul-minn?lite
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_Richmond_High_School_gang_rape
enough examples? how about statistics?
US NATIONAL RAPE/SEXUAL ASSAULT STATISTICS
According to a study conducted by the US National Victim Center, 1.3 women (age 18 and over) in the United States are forcibly raped each minute. That translates to 78 an hour, 1,871 per day, or 683,000 per year. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, nearly 6 out of 10 rape/sexual assault incidents are reported by victims to have occurred in their own home or at the home of a friend, relative, or neighbor.51% of the sexual assault cases studied in the Women’s Safety Project survey were committed against young women between 16 and 21 years old.According to the U.S. Department of Justice, Only 16% of rapes are ever reported to the police. In a survey of victims who did not report rape or attempted rape to the police, the following was found as to why no report was made: 43% thought nothing could be done, 27% felt it was a private matter, 12% were afraid of police response, and 12% felt it was not important enough.13.3% of college women indicated that they had been forced to have sex in a dating situation.In a national survey 27.7% of college women reported a sexual experience since the age of fourteen that met the legal definition of rape or attempted rape, and 7.7% of college men reported perpetrating aggressive behavior which met the legal definition of rape.Among developmentally disabled adults, as many as 83% of the females and 32% of the males are the victims of sexual assault.16% of male students surveyed by the Ms. Foundation who had committed rape, and 10% of those who attempted a rape, took part in episodes involving multiple perpetrators.Women with disabilities are raped and abused at a rate at least twice that of the general population of women.
Drac: The burqa is the least of the problems women have to face in those countries. In India, because male children are more valuable to the parents, the educate the males, and seldom the females (unless it's a missionary school), and on many cases, girl babies are abandoned, especially in poor families. One of the reasons is that girls are supposed to bring a dowry with them when they get married, as opposed to the Lobolo in South Africa, which is a gift the groom gives to the family of the bride (bride price) to compensate them for the loss of a valued family member. Poor families cannot afford a good dowry to get the girl married higher up in society, even if they could break through the caste mentality. As long as you have society with customs that the female's family pays you to take their daughter, you can't fix the anti-woman mentality. I do believe that the US should get involved - not in this trial, but in India's safety issue for women, and tell India that if they want foreign aid, they have to do better.
Incidentally, a friend of mine (American) wore a burqa in Afghanistan when she lived there with her Afghan husband and she said it wasn't as bad as people think. Because you're covered, you can wear whatever you want under it, and it's not as heavy as you think.
They should hang this lawyer together with the rapists.
No "respected" attorney in India would touch this case - and that's true.
so friggin what if it may not be A RESPECTED LADY?? Does he actually think the MEN doing the raping are RESPECTFUL??? HELLO??? Anyone home in his brain?? What an intelligent remark...Boy these men sure know how to piss a RESPECTED LADY off!! Send them to the U.S. ...We will teach these pathetic males what respect is all about and that they aren't the only ones who can abuse....They need to climb down off the throne they have put themselves on and realize how the world views them....Them and their lawyer are scum of the earth with a very sick mindset. Just because they carry a penis they think that is an entitlement to do as they please and harm others??? Bring it to my front door and I will show them what they are entitled to...
Don't sugar coat it, BeachN, tell us how you really feel! Many of us "carry a penis" but are responsible, mature, adults who have respect for others, including women. But yeah, these rapists and their scumbag lawyer are the lowest form of life - even animals wouldn't do what they've done.
Beach... you size queen. Lower your font please.. it is blinding. We get your point either way. (I think I am getting "Font-envy").
Attorney practicing practicing 'Sharia Laws' coming to USSA.
Jack Kinch: what did her post have to do with sharia laws? As for the USSA - we dodged that bullet when we dumped Romney at the polls. If you don't like the USA as it is, I can suggest that you head on over to Iran, Russia, or any other country, because we don't like UnAmerican comments here.
And here I thought Afghanistan and Pakistan were backward countries. Or that place called...I believe it's the American South? Huh. That can't be right.
I think it's called Steubenville, Ohio.
Just when you think you've heard it all, now this. Perhaps one may someday be able to say of this "attorney:" Until today I have not seen a single incident or example of rape with a respected attorney. My view of India has changed for the worse because of this case and the apparent injustice in that country.
Sounds just like the "legitimate rape" argument in this country. Doesn't the "weaker sex" have "a mechanism to shut it down" if they really didn't want it? To me they are all the same morons and scum backs, no matter the country.
All a woman has to do to shut it down in this country, as far as I am concerned - is say "no".
After that - it's rape. Doesn't matter how far it's gone or how horny the guy is - no is no. The guy can refer to her as a cocktease or a bitch later - no is no.
Actually, the default answer is already "no."
She doesn't have to say no. She has to say YES, and if you don't hear a YES, then the answer is always NO!
If more people would only understand this...
In my military career, I have been in 26 countries. Some good..some that make you go - WTF? It's really hard to believe what other human beings put up with - you see it - and...well, due to SOFA, you can't change it.
Unfortunately, abuse of women is not uncommon. There are many countries with laws that favor men over women - even when the crimes are obvious. Think...stoning. There are laws in countries that will punish WOMEN for losing their virginity....to men...that go unpunished.
Removing The Eyes Of A Pedophile Will Ensure The Safety Of Another Child.
that includes murderers and rapists. castration is not the answer. When a victim is murdered, their vision has been taken away. the same for a child or adult who is raped and if they survive , they have to live with the trauma for the rest of their life. let the punishment fit the crime. take an eye for an eye. i think we've been misinterpreting the bible........death is too good for this type of filth...........and eye for an eye.....then let a family member Protect House and F E E D the P I G S three meals a day.....enough is enough
Not disagreeing, but there is no way that we can live by old testament law. The largest harm is done by the people that are NOT caught - those that are still secret - and by old testament law - unpunished.
The same could be said for the scarlet letter - sure - it stands out - but what of all of those that are doing the same deed that are not caught?
Glass houses and stones. I have my skeletons in my closet just like ALL of us do. Were my dalliances to become public, no doubt I would be as a minimum embarrassed, if not in jail. I try not to think of anyone as being more screwed up or less screwed up than I am - I am a model citizen in public - in private - well.... And that is NO different than ANYONE else - those that deviate TOO far (and are caught anyway) are punished and held up to public scrutiny.
We have laws against cruel and unusual punishment here. I am all for life without parole for a pedophile conviction, and I'm all for the death penalty for a pedophile conviction. But if you give that penalty for the conviction, the first thing that's going to happen is it will be appealed due to the cruel and unusual punishment. That is IF that penalty even gets to the point where it's considered. No matter how much you revile these people, if the penalty is successfully appealed, then their conviction will be up to some judge who may decide to let him be paroled. Many pedophile, murderer, rapist etc lose their families when they commit the crime - so that is sentencing THEM if they have to take care of the POS. These people need to be given sentences that keep them out of the general population - be it life in prison without parole, or death. But they also need to have the law read that life in prison without the possibility of parole means no parole even if the prison is over crowded or the budget gets cut.