Mexico City seeks cause of deadly Pemex blast; attack not ruled out

Miguel Tovar/stf / Getty Images

The aftermath of a deadly explosion at the complex that houses Pemex, Mexico's state-run oil monopoly, in Mexico City on Thursday.

MEXICO CITY — Mexico's government vowed on Friday to find out whether an explosion that killed 33 people at the headquarters of its state-run oil monopoly Pemex was a deliberate attack or yet another stain on the company's safety record.

Rescue workers continued to pull bodies from the debris on Friday and officials said the search would continue until they account for everyone inside the Mexico City building.

Government officials have refused to speculate over what caused the explosion on Thursday but said they had deployed large teams of experts to pore through the wreckage.


The government is determined to find out the truth, whatever that may be ... whether it was an accident, negligence or an attack, whatever," Attorney General Jesus Murillo said on Friday evening. "We are not going to rule out anything."


He said the explosion did not cause a fire but refused to be drawn on what that implied about the cause. Parts of the reinforced concrete ground floor of the building caved in, and the ceiling was a mess of twisted metal pipes and ducts.

The blast at Pemex's complex in the capital killed at least 33 people and a further 121 were injured. The scenes of chaos have dealt another blow to Pemex's image, just as Mexico's new government is seeking to open up the oil industry to more private investment.

Speculation over the cause has ranged from a bomb attack, to a gas leak, to a boiler blowing up.

"A fatal incident like yesterday's cannot be explained in two hours. We are working with the best teams in Mexico and from overseas. We will not speculate," Pemex's chief executive, Emilio Lozoya, said on Friday.

National mourning
New President Enrique Pena Nieto declared three days of national mourning.

Pemex, which was created when Mexico nationalized its oil industry in 1938, is a symbol of self-sufficiency but it has also been blighted by corruption, inefficiency and frequent accidents costing hundreds of lives.

The latest Pemex disaster is one of the first serious tests for Pena Nieto, who must overcome the legacy of his Institutional Revolutionary Party, or PRI, which ruled for much of the last century.

After seven decades in power, the party gained a reputation for corruption and cover-ups that have made Mexicans skeptical of whether they are being told the truth.

Investors have been closely following how far he will go in enticing private capital to boost flagging oil output in a country that is the world's seventh biggest producer.

"This incident speaks very poorly of the image of Pemex management, and that's interpreted as additional risk in the market,"said Miriam Grunstein, an energy researcher at Mexico's CIDE think tank.

A Pemex official said the damaged area of the company's headquarters was used for human resources in the corporate and refining divisions. It did not have a boiler or gas installations, the official said.

Former Pemex worker Ricardo Marin, 53, said there was nothing in the building that would explode and that the kitchen, where there would be gas, was on the other side.

"The only thing that occurs to me is that it was an attack — but against whom? There's no one with an important job down there," he said, waiting outside the Pemex hospital where a friend was in intensive care. "Maybe it could be a message to Pena Nieto, but not even that has any logic."

Pemex office worker Alfonso Caballero, who was one floor above the blast at the time, said he did not smell any gas and guessed it had been caused by machinery.

Mexican officials have not ruled out sabotage.

An official at the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives said an "international response team" was on its way to Mexico City at the request of the Mexican government. The team includes explosive specialists and fire experts.

Pemex CEO Lozoya said the four floors most affected by the explosion normally had about 200 to 250 people working on them.

About 10,000 staff work in the entire complex.

Red Cross official Isaac Oxenhaut said the ceiling had collapsed in three lower floors of the Pemex building.

Safety in the spotlight
The blast followed a September fire at a Pemex gas facility near the northern city of Reynosa that killed 30 people. More than 300 were killed when a Pemex natural gas plant on the outskirts of Mexico City blew up in 1984.

Eight years later, about 200 people were killed and 1,500 injured after a series of underground gas explosions in Guadalajara, Mexico's second-biggest city. An official investigation found Pemex was partly to blame.

Whatever caused the explosion, the deaths and destruction will put the spotlight back on safety at Pemex, which only a couple of hours beforehand had issued a statement on Twitter saying it had managed to improve its record on accidents.

"I suspect this was a bomb," said David Shields, an independent Mexico City-based oil analyst. "There are clandestine armies across Mexico, not just the (drug) cartels."

Shields pointed to the bombing of several Pemex pipelines in the eastern state of Veracruz in 2007. A shadowy Marxist rebel movement took credit for some of the blasts.

Meanwhile, George Baker, director of Energia.com, a Houston-based energy research center, said past history suggested the government could seek to exploit the incident.

He pointed to the 1992 Guadalajara blast and the subsequent deal that followed to overhaul the Pemex administration led by then-President Carlos Salinas, like Pena Nieto a PRI member.

"Salinas said he wanted a response from Pemex, and months later Pemex announced a restructuring. The restructuring had nothing to do with the Guadalajara accident, but it was used as a pivot to do something," Baker said.

Pena Nieto has yet to reveal details of his Pemex reform plan, which already faces opposition from the left.

Both Pena Nieto and his finance minister were this week at pains to stress the company will not be privatized.

Related:

At least 33 dead in Mexico City skyscraper explosion

Discuss this post

If its not a gas build up, which it doesn't appear to be, it has to be a bomb. Things don't just explode for no reason.

The meaning behind the bomb, is the question. Being its Mexico, i'm guessing its an extortion demand of some kind. Either for money, or as a warning to someone. Obviously Mexico has its hands full dealing with something.

    Reply#1 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 1:57 AM EST
    Mexi-ObamaDeleted
    bow2meDeleted

    Such buildings typically consume between 1 and 5 megawatts so there will be large oil-filled transformers in the basement.

    No bomb is necessary as it is already there! The transformer can be the bomb. All it needs is a bad gasket on the transformer lid. (The leak has to be above the oil level otherwise it will be noticed) Over the years the transformer "breathes" and the oil absorbs moisture. The rest of the tale needs no explanation.

      #1.3 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 7:11 PM EST
      Reply

      Obviously Mexico has its hands full dealing with something.

        Reply#2 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 2:35 AM EST

        Mexico--has cost the United States tax payers alot of money

        $113,000,000,000.00-The cost of illegal Mexicans in 2012---with 70% of the cost passed on to the States

        1,400,000 -Illegal Mexican households getting benefits---food stamps--supplementary social security--subsudized housing--wic--medicaid-- free phone--while Americans are living in homeless camps---cars--- Syria has received over $175,000,000.00 this week--thanks to the U.S. tax payer

        • 4 votes
        Reply#3 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 7:27 AM EST

        You know I've actuallly read posts from people who were jealous of the benefits people receive in prison - kind of like milllionaires who are jealous of people lesss fortunate than themselves being able to acquire Health Care for themselves and their families.

        • 1 vote
        #3.1 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 9:53 AM EST

        Cobra -

        You stand corrected. Your computer surely has a search engine. Use it. Google "welfare to illegal aliens."

        • 1 vote
        #3.3 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 12:51 PM EST

        Cobra..

        Don't know who you think is the idiot here but it is NOT mpa.

        Illegals get all kinds of social services in the US. There are huge signs in both English and Spanish in all social services offices that state they are not allowed to ask about citizenship before providing assistance.

        it is a well known fact that illegals are eligible for social services.

        • 1 vote
        #3.5 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 5:02 PM EST

        screminmimi

        Actually Cobra is correct, you need to separate your personal issues with Mexicans, from the truth. Give us actual proof that "illegals" actually costs the usa that much...you cant because they are lies!

        Mexicans are the best people in this world, your stupidity won´t let you see that.

        Besides this is a forum about people in Mexico, why are you even on here, spewing your krap about illegal immigration?

        • 1 vote
        #3.6 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 5:42 PM EST
        bow2meDeleted

        Cobra..

        You are incorrect in thinking that only illegals who have anchor babies who are American citizens can get social services.

        There is no requirement to be an American citizen to receive social services in America. As an example I give you President Obama's illegal aunt and an illegal uncle, both living in different areas of the US for over twenty years, and both receiving free housing, free food stamps, free medical care, and other free social services.

        Neither of them, to my knowledge, had any anchor babies. They have been under deportation orders for years and have ignored them, living free off taxpayers in spite of being illegal aliens.

        And they are not Mexicans. My problem is not with Mexicans, it is with illegal aliens.

          #3.9 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 8:15 PM EST
          Reply

          Wait. Mexico has oil?

            Reply#4 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 9:29 AM EST

            Mexico exports crude but has no refineries so they import gasoline.

            • 1 vote
            #4.1 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 9:36 AM EST

            Good thing Cheney didn't know that or we would have invaded Mexico instead of Iraq (which has obviously paid for itself.)

            • 1 vote
            #4.2 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 9:54 AM EST
            Reply

            Mexi-Obama - you could not have shown lesss understanding of Mexico and/or Latin AMerica if you had posted, "I am a dunce who gets alll his opinions from the radio."

              Reply#5 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 9:52 AM EST

              On March 18, 1938, citing the 27th article of the 1917 constitution, President Cárdenas embarked on the state-expropriation of all resources and facilities, nationalizing the United States and AngloDutch operating companies, creating Pemex. In retaliation, many foreign governments closed their markets to Mexican oil. In spite of the boycott, Pemex developed into one of the largest oil companies in the world and helped Mexico become the fifth-largest oil exporter in the world.

              Despite its current $80.6 billion in revenue, Pemex pays high taxes that contribute a large portion of the budget of the federal government. In recent years the company has only been able to make ends meet through massive borrowing, so that it now owes a staggering $42.5 billion, including $24 billion in off-balance-sheet debt because the Mexican government treats the company as a major source of revenue. The state-owned company pays out over 60% of its revenue in royalties and taxes, and those funds pay for 40% of the federal government's budget

                #5.1 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 10:26 AM EST
                Reply

                I'm in Europe but from what I've heard on the news the electricity in the building became erratic before the explosion. I'd guess that there are large transformers in the basement that transform 11,000 volts down to ordinary household voltage. I'd surmise that the transformer(s) would be of at least a megawatt and possibly more if the building is air-conditioned.

                Such transformers are usually oil filled. It is possible for the oil to become degraded over time particularly with moisture from the atmosphere. If this should happen the oil may fail to insulate. Once the oil breaks down it gives off gas but usually this will be detected by a Buchholz Relay. The Buchholz Relay then trips-off the circuit breaker that switches the incoming power.

                If there is no Buchholz Relay or if it is faulty there is the risk of a severe explosion.

                About fifty years ago I was working at a premises where the oil in a 500KVA house supplies transformer had failed its voltage breakdown test. Fortunately there was a duplicate transformer which was OK so it was not a problem. The bad oil was cleaned with a "Metafilter" machine which extracted two and a half buckets of water from the oil. The filtering took three days running twenty four hours per day. After that the oil was returned to the transformer. OK employing Technical Support people does cost money but explosions, litigation and compensation costs more.

                  Reply#6 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 4:44 PM EST
                  bow2meDeleted

                  This whole thing could have been caused by some idiot that had a huge gripe with someone at the company and couldn't figure out a better way to deal with there own anger and comes up with a stupid plan that puts many other people who had nothing to do with his problems at risk.

                  Maybe they went online and find out how to make some kind of crude bomb and somehow end up making it wrong or adding to much of one ingredient or another and all of a sudden we have a huge explosion that has cost many folks that had nothing to do with his problem in the first place there lives, all because someone couldn't handle some kind of problem by getting help before putting innocent people in harms way.

                  If by a rare chance I'm right about all of this I sure hope that whoever is found to have caused this suffers greatly for this crime against many innocent people who only trying to do there jobs and live a decent life.

                  I do not care one bit for any person who comes into the US illegally but this whole event has no place anywhere as it affects many innocent people and I feel for all there families.

                  Hopefully there isn't some kind of cover up when this is all over with, the truth would be nice for all the people who were affected by this, good luck with that though as its Mexico, not like it would be any different here in the United states either the way things are going for us.

                  Just my 2 cents on the matter.

                    Reply#8 - Sat Feb 2, 2013 7:13 PM EST
                    bow2meDeleted
                    Reply
                    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.