• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
Advertise | AdChoices
  • Recommended: Thousands rally in Italy to oppose austerity measures
  • Recommended: 'Love has won out over hate': France becomes 14th country to allow gay marriage
  • Recommended: Shots fired at Cannes film festival, actors flee for cover
  • Recommended: North Korea fires three short-range missiles off east coast

First for breaking news and analysis: Compelling world news stories from NBC News journalists. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook.

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • 5
    Oct
    2012
    3:33pm, EDT

    Canada's top court says some HIV carriers may withhold condition from partners

    By NBC News staff and wire services

    Canada's top court said on Friday that failing to tell a sexual partner you have HIV is only sexual assault if there is "a realistic possibility" of transmitting the virus that causes AIDS.


    Follow @NBCNewsWorld

    In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court of Canada rejected the government's argument that everyone who has HIV should be required to disclose that condition to all sexual partners in any circumstance.

    Several groups involved in the case, including the Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network and the Canadian AIDS Society, took issue with the court's standard of a "realistic possibility," saying it is too severe, and calling the decision "a major step backwards for public health and human rights."

    The HIV groups said in a release that the risk of spreading HIV is made negligible just by using condoms, and that the court's decision "blatantly ignores solid science."


    "What you're talking about here is a vulnerable, marginalized group of people who are going to be forced to go around volunteering to anyone with whom they're going to have sexual contact, that they belong to that vulnerable, marginalized group," Michael Feder, a lawyer for the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, told the CBC.

    In 1998, the court found that not telling a partner about one's HIV status was a form of aggravated sexual assault if there was "significant risk of bodily harm." On Friday, the court clarified what might constitute a significant risk.

    It said someone with a low viral load who uses a condom has not put their partner at significant risk. Viral load measures the severity of HIV infection, and some treatments reduce the level, making transmission less likely.

    "As noted by the court of appeal, the transmissibility of HIV is proportional to the viral load, i.e. the quantity of HIV copies in the blood," the decision said, according to City News. "The viral load of an untreated HIV patient ranges from 10,000 copies to a few million copies per millilitre.

    Stay informed with the latest headlines; sign up for our newsletter

    "When a patient undergoes anti-retroviral treatment, the viral load shrinks rapidly to less than 1,500 copies per millilitre (low viral load), and can even be brought down to less than 50 copies per millilitre (undetectable viral load) over a longer period of time. This appears to be scientifically accepted at this point, on the evidence in this case," the decision said.

    The court noted that standards might change in future cases since its decision does not preclude the law from "adapting to future advances in treatment" or risk factors it had not directly considered.

    It said that risk of transmission, rather than actual transmission, is not a crime in many other countries, and that this "sounds a note of caution against extending the criminal law beyond its appropriate reach in this complex and emerging area of law."

    Watch World News videos on NBCNews.com

    Forcing everyone to disclose their HIV status would risk sending people who have not put anyone at risk to prison, the court said.

    Two cases were considered by the court, the first one involving a man who had sex with nine women, including a 12-year-old girl, after being diagnosed with HIV in 2004, CBC reported. Clato Mabior didn't tell the women he was HIV positive.

    None of the women contracted the disease, City News said. The Supreme Court set aside one of Mabior's convictions because in that respective situation he used a condom and had a low viral load. In Mabior's case, this decision has little consequence, since he was deported to South Sudan in February, City News said.

    In the second case, a Quebec woman who had unprotected sex with her partner in 2000 did not tell him she was HIV-positive.

    According to City News, the woman had been taking anti-retroviral drugs after she was diagnosed with HIV nine years earlier.

    "Here low — indeed undetectable — viral load was established," the Supreme Court concluded, according to City News.

    The court affirmed an earlier appeal court decision to strike down the woman's conviction for aggravated assault and sexual assault.

    Reuters contributed to this report.

    More world stories from NBC News:

    • Court: Kenyans tortured by colonial regime can sue UK
    • Tourists fined as Rome declares 'War on the Sandwich'
    • Mourning, sighs of relief in Turkish town shelled by Syria
    • Venezuela vote: Oil wealth to trump calls for change?
    • Inside Syria with Ann Curry
    • Scientists: Great Barrier Reef coral seeing 'major decline'
    • Saudi Arabia's Ikea catalog is missing something: women
    • From war zones, photographer brings scars, searing images
    • Death threats force Afghan actress into hiding
    • Stay informed: Sign up for our newsletter

    Follow World News from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook

    131 comments

    Isn't that like saying it is okay to shoot at someone if you are bad at aiming?

    Show more
    Explore related topics: canada, aids, hiv, featured

Browse

  • featured,
  • world-news,
  • syria,
  • china,
  • europe,
  • afghanistan,
  • world,
  • middle-east,
  • israel,
  • egypt,
  • pakistan,
  • iran,
  • russia,
  • updated,
  • uk,
  • north-korea,
  • africa,
  • london,
  • military,
  • assad,
  • france,
  • protest,
  • environment,
  • al-qaida,
  • britain,
  • taliban,
  • nuclear,
  • italy,
  • india,
  • terrorism,
  • asia,
  • germany,
  • japan,
  • vatican,
  • economy,
  • crime,
  • human-rights,
  • mexico,
  • south-africa,
  • pope
Also
Advertise | AdChoices

Archives

  • 2013
    • May (144)
    • April (275)
    • March (432)
    • February (332)
    • January (323)
  • 2012
    • December (332)
    • November (332)
    • October (313)
    • September (360)
    • August (362)
    • July (310)
    • June (351)
    • May (427)
    • April (404)
    • March (427)
    • February (347)
    • January (284)
  • 2011
    • December (357)
    • November (3)

Most Commented

  • Girl's organs removed after vacation death; family believes they may have been sold (610)
  • Never too late: Nazi hunters tirelessly pursue 50 elderly Auschwitz war criminals (701)
  • A saint-making record is also a diplomatic headache for Pope Francis (590)
  • Chef to the stars Miki Nozawa dies following confrontation over unpaid bill (411)
  • Price of a night's sleep? Israel reportedly spends $127K to build bedroom on PM's plane (441)
  • Two waiters arrested in killing of Malcolm X's grandson in Mexico (412)
  • Japanese mayor: WWII 'comfort women' sex slaves 'necessary' for morale (387)

Other blogs

  • The Body Odd
  • Cosmic Log
  • Red Tape Chronicles
  • PhotoBlog
  • US News
  • Open Channel

NBCNews.com top stories

3147,10
© 2013 NBCNews.com
  • World news on NBCNews.com
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Site map
  • Careers
  • Closed captioning
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertise