• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
Advertise | AdChoices
  • Recommended: 50 years after iconic JFK speech, Obama honors 'magic' moment in Berlin
  • Recommended: Brazil officials reverse subway, bus fare hike
  • Recommended: Kerry calls Afghanistan's Karzai to ease anger over Taliban office
  • Recommended: Fashion designers Dolce and Gabbana guilty of tax evasion in Italy

First for breaking news and analysis: Compelling world news stories from NBC News journalists. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook.

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • 6
    Mar
    2013
    11:10am, EST

    Australia: 'Prisoner X' worked for Israeli government

    William West / AFP - Getty Images, file

    Australian newspapers lead their front pages on Feb. 14 with the story of Ben Zygier, known as "Prisoner X".

    By Peter Jeary, Senior Foreign Desk Editor, NBC News

    The murky world of state-sponsored espionage has come under the spotlight in an Australian government report about the death of a man known as "Prisoner X" in a maximum-security Israeli prison.

    Ben Zygier, who had dual Australian and Israeli citizenship, was arrested in January 2010 and was found hanged in his cell in an apparent suicide in December 2010.


    Follow @NBCNewsWorld


    His identity and reasons for confinement were unknown until he was named last month following an investigation by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

    A report released Tuesday by Australian Foreign Minister, Bob Carr, shed some light on the case.

    Australian media have said Zygier was imprisoned because Israel suspected he had disclosed secret details of Mossad operations.

    The report confirmed Zygier was an employee of the Israeli government at the time of his arrest.

    Carr stopped short of identifying Zygier as a Mossad agent, but told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation Tuesday that "open-source material" suggested Zygier "worked for the intelligence arm of the Israeli government."

    "You can draw your own conclusions," he added.

    'Significant uncertainty'
    Israel's government has refused to release details about the Zygier case, even after a gag order that barred Israeli media from reporting on it was partially lifted. 

    The Australian report said that Zygier, who had lived in Israel for about ten years before his death, had been arrested by Israeli authorities on charges of national security.

    The charges he faced carried penalties of up to 20 years in jail, but not the death penalty, it added.

    "Significant uncertainty exists around the details of Israel’s handling of the arrest, detention and legal processes of Mr. Zygier," the report said.

    But the government would await the outcome of "various inquiries underway or foreshadowed in Israel" before seeking further information, it said. Zygier had three Australian passports, all legally obtained, issued in his birth name and two other names following official name changes. He held only one passport at any one time.

    Andrew Brownbill / AP, file

    The grave of Ben Zygier, who died in an apparent suicide in 2010 in a maximum-security Israeli prison, at Chevra Kadisha Jewish Cemetery in Melbourne, Australia.

    However, the report identified "the broader issue of the misuse of Australian passports by Israeli intelligence" as a concern of national security at the time of Zygier’s incarceration.

    Although there was no suggestion that Zygier was involved in this misuse — or that he obtained his passports fraudulently — the government report said, "If media reports prove to be true that Mr. Zygier used his passport in the service of Israeli intelligence, this would raise significant questions about the appropriateness of this activity."

    The issue of misused passports is particularly sensitive for Australia.

    In 2010, an Australian investigation concluded that Israel had counterfeited four Australian passports used by the suspected hit squad that murdered a Hamas official in Dubai.

    Australia retaliated by expelling an Israeli diplomat. Carr said there was no evidence Zygier was involved in the Dubai killing.

    Related:

    Controversy erupts on two continents over Israel's 'Prisoner X'

    78 comments

    Zygier is a perfect example of dual loyalty Jews, used to spy on people in their own native country, in this case Australia. Perhaps he had some misgivings about the evil he was required to perform against Australia. For that, he was killed by the Israeli government. America was betrayed by the same …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: israel, australia, mossad, intelligence, featured, prisoner-x, ben-zygier
  • Updated
    18
    Feb
    2013
    2:07am, EST

    Israel to probe death of alleged Mossad recruit

    Ronen Zvulun / Reuters

    Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government has restricted reporting in Israel on the case, which is overshadowing his victory in a national election held last month.

    By Dan Williams and Allyn Fisher, Reuters

    JERUSALEM - Israeli lawmakers announced plans on Sunday to investigate the 2010 jailhouse death of a reported Australian immigrant recruit to the Mossad spy agency.

    The statement by Parliament's Foreign Affairs and Defence Committee followed calls by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at a cabinet meeting to dim a growing media spotlight on the affair he saw as at risk of jeopardizing national security.

    The case kept under wraps for two years then publicized by Australian television last Tuesday involves a 34-year-old immigrant, Ben Zygier, said to be a Mossad operative held on suspicion of security offences, who died of what has been labeled an apparent suicide behind bars.

    In a terse communique, the legislative panel's subcommittee on intelligence said it has "decided to conduct an intensive examination of all aspects of the incident involving the prisoner found dead in his (prison) cell in December 2010."

    While unlikely to have any immediate political consequences the investigation may lead to a wider inquiry with potentially broader repercussions.

    Netanyahu's government has restricted reporting in Israel on the case, now overshadowing his victory in a national election held last month, using court gag orders, military censorship and direct requests to news editors.

    Such steps have done little to douse demands for the authorities to come clean about the circumstances of Zygier's imprisonment and how he was able to kill himself in a highly-supervised isolation cell.

    Without citing the case specifically, Netanyahu said on Sunday he "absolutely trusts" Israel's security services and what he described as the independent legal monitoring system under which they operated.

    "We are an exemplary democracy," Netanyahu said in remarks aired by Israeli broadcasters.

    "But we are also more threatened, more challenged, and therefore we have to ensure the proper operation of our security branches," Netanyahu also said.

    "Therefore I ask over everyone: Let the security services continue working quietly so that we can continue to live in safety and tranquility in the State of Israel."

    The few Israeli officials who have spoken of Zygier's case have not denied that he was linked to Mossad, which in early 2010 was accused by Dubai of using Australian passport-holders to assassinate a Palestinian arms procurer in the Gulf emirate.

    Media reports have speculated that Israel suspected the Melbourne-born Jew of betraying or threatening to divulge Mossad missions, perhaps to Australia's security services, as they probed passport fraud.

    Civil liberties groups and some Israeli lawmakers have demanded to know whether Zygier's rights were violated by his months of incarceration under alias.

    'Grave charges'
    In an apparent reversal from previous statements, Australian Foreign Minister Bob Carr said on Thursday his ministry had known about Zygier's jailing as early as February 2010. On Wednesday he said Australian diplomats in Israel only found out about the detention after his death in custody later that year.

    Avigdor Feldman, an Israeli lawyer with whom Zygier consulted in Ayalon prison, said last week that that meeting was arranged by a "Mossad liaison" and that his client had denied "grave charges" for which he awaited trial.

    Feldman also said that Zygier's family, which has declined all comment on the affair, knew about his detention. The incarceration was approved by several Israeli courts.

    Two senior cabinet members, Intelligence Minister Dan Meridor and Strategic Affairs Minister Moshe Yaalon, told Israeli media on Saturday the case was rare but lawful.

    "There are extreme situations...to do with our security and even the need to preserve human life, when we need to take an extreme step such as this," Yaalon told Channel Two television.

    Meridor said that publishing the prisoner's identity would have risked "serious harm to security." He did not elaborate.

    Tzachi Hanegbi, a lawmaker from Netanyahu's conservative Likud party said he had never been informed of Zygier's arrest as chairman of the parliamentary defence panel at the time.

    "This requires explanation," Hanegbi said. "Usually, every significant subject, whether it is impressive achievements or embarrassing failures, is laid out before the subcommittee."

    Former Mossad director Danny Yatom told Reuters the agency was under no legal obligation to brief oversight lawmakers in such circumstances.

    Related:

    Controversy erupts on two continents over Israel's 'Prisoner X'

    Israel confirms jailing mystery foreigner

    This story was originally published on Sun Feb 17, 2013 8:30 PM EST

    34 comments

    Never trust israel zionist government.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: israel, australia, mossad, featured, netanyahu, updated, prisoner-x, ben-zygier
  • 13
    Feb
    2013
    4:21pm, EST

    Israel confirms jailing mystery foreigner

    By Dan Williams, Reuters

    Israel broke its official silence on Wednesday over the reported suicide in jail of an Australian immigrant recruited to its spy service Mossad, giving limited details on a closely guarded case.

    After appeals by local media chafing at Israeli censorship of a story broken by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC), a district court near Tel Aviv allowed publication of six paragraphs of sanctioned text - a de-facto preliminary account by the state.

    The text said that an Israeli with an unspecified dual nationality had been secretly imprisoned "out of security considerations", only to be found dead in his cell two years ago in what was eventually ruled a suicide.

    The district court did not confirm or deny ABC's unsourced findings that the dead man was 34-year-old Ben Zygier, an Australian who moved to Israel and may have been jailed in isolation over suspected misconduct while spying for Mossad.


    Follow @NBCNewsWorld

    Social media records showed that Zygier, who died in late 2010 and was buried in Melbourne, had been married with children. His relatives have declined all comment on the case.

    The Israeli district court said the unnamed detainee had been held under the supervision "of the most senior officials of the Justice Ministry" and that his family had been informed of his arrest immediately after it took place.

    After citing other legal monitoring mechanisms in the case, the district court said: "Beyond this no details can be published about the affair, for reasons of national security."

    Prisoner X
    Israeli media had earlier quoted the ABC and other foreign reports about Zygier, dubbed "Prisoner X", some of which suggested he had been under investigation by Australia's security services on suspicion of using his native passport for Mossad missions in countries hostile to the Jewish state.

    The possibility that a Mossad officer had been treated so harshly drew comparisons to known previous cases when Israel jailed turncoat spies under blanket secrecy, sometimes lasting years.

    Israeli intelligence veterans said such measures reduced the risk of enemy countries where the detainees had served learning of their true identities and then tracing their activities in order to expose other spies still under cover.

    Mossad is widely reputed to have stepped up its shadow war in recent years against Iran's nuclear program, Lebanon's Hezbollah guerrillas, suspected nuclear procurement by Syria and arms smuggling to Palestinians through Dubai, Sudan and Egypt.

    Yet the official secrecy over the Zygier report, reinforced by military censors, caused an outcry in Israel, where reporters noted that their compatriots were but a mouse-click away from learning about the case from foreign media on the internet.

    In a highly unusual move within hours of the ABC broadcast, Israeli editors were summoned to an emergency meeting in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office on Tuesday and asked not to publish a story "that is very embarrassing to a certain government agency," Israel's liberal Haaretz newspaper reported.

    Haaretz ridiculed the gag order as outmoded and counter-productive, but one of the editors who attended the meeting, Yinon Magal of the Walla news-site, was more circumspect.

    The explanation he had received for the secrecy, Magal told Israel's Channel 10 television, "persuaded me, overall, that there is a certain logic, albeit small, that there are considerations of national security and of human life here."

    Related:

    Controversy erupts on two continents over Israel's 'Prisoner X'

    Copyright 2013 Thomson Reuters. Click for restrictions.

    58 comments

    Mossad is responsible for the safety of a tiny country surrounded by other countries bent on destroying them. From the day Israel became a state in 1948, they have been attacked by other nations, terrorist organizations, and surrogate groups funded by other nations.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: israel, australia, mossad, featured, prisoner-x
  • 13
    Feb
    2013
    9:32am, EST

    Controversy erupts on two continents over Israel's 'Prisoner X'

    Julian Smith / Australian Associated Press via EPA

    Is this the last resting place of "Prisoner X"? The tombstone of Ben Zygier at the Chevra Kadisha Jewish Cemetery in Melbourne, Australia. EDITOR'S NOTE: This image was manipulated by the Australian Associated Press to obscure the names of children on the tombstone for privacy reasons.

    By Ian Johnston and Alexandra Hess, NBC News

    A storm of controversy erupted on two continents Wednesday after a television station claimed to have identified the inmate of a high-security Israeli jail previously known only as "Prisoner X."

    The Australian Broadcasting Corporation reported Tuesday that the inmate was Ben Zygier, 34, also known as Ben Alon and Ben Allen. It described him as a married father of two who was originally from Australia but who later moved to Israel.

    It said he was found hanged in his cell --  originally built for Yigal Amir, who assassinated Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin -- in 2010, and that he had been buried in Melbourne, Australia, a few weeks later. 

    The report said Zygier had been recruited by Israeli spy agency Mossad, but it did not cite a source for this information. NBC News was unable to independently verify the report.

    In 2010, the prisoner’s case was highlighted by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel, which wrote to the country’s attorney-general saying it was “alarming” that someone was being detained “incommunicado and we know nothing about him,” the broadcaster reported.

    But the attorney-general’s assistant replied that a “gag order” imposed by the Israeli government preventing media reports about the case was “vital for preventing a serious breach of the state’s security, so we cannot elaborate about this affair,” it added.

    The case of the prisoner, also known as "Mr. X," first came to public attention when a story appeared briefly on the Ynet news website in 2010, according to the U.K.'s Telegraph newspaper. "He is simply a person without a name and without an identity who has been placed in total and utter isolation from the outside world," a prison official reportedly said.

    The Ynet report was taken down after a few hours, the Telegraph said.


    Follow @NBCNewsWorld

    'Very embarrassing'
    Within hours of Tuesday's report surfacing, Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office summoned editors to ask them not to publish a story "that is very embarrassing to a certain government agency," Israel's Haaretz newspaper said.

    "The emergency meeting was called following a broadcast outside Israel regarding the incident in question," Haaretz added, giving no further information.

    Shortly afterwards, all reference to the Australian report vanished from Israeli news websites, Reuters reported.

    However, Israeli politicians then began asking about the case in the Knesset, the country's parliament, prompting media reports about the case.

    “Are there people in prisons whose incarceration is kept secret? What are the supervision mechanisms on this kind of imprisonment?” lawmaker Dov Henin asked Tuesday, according to The Jerusalem Post. “What are the possibilities for parliamentary supervision on such incarcerations?”

    Another lawmaker, Zehava Gal-On, expressed concern about the involvement of the media in keeping quiet about Prisoner X, the Post reported. “Today, we hear that in a country that claims to be a civilized democracy, journalists cooperate with the government, and that anonymous prisoners, who no one knew existed, commit suicide,” she said.

    Justice Minister Yaakov Neeman told the Knesset that more details about the case would eventually be made known, the Post reported.

    Trained as lawyer
    The case is also raising questions in Australia.

    In an emailed statement Wednesday, a spokesperson for Australia’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said that “an internal review of the department’s handling of this consular case” had begun.

    In a follow-up to its original story, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation quoted a spokeswoman for Australia's Foreign Affairs Minister Bob Carr as saying that “some officers of the department were made aware of Mr. Allen's detention at the time in 2010 by another Australian agency.”

    Writing in The Australian Financial Review, Patrick Durkin said he had trained as a lawyer with Zygier in 2001.

    “I remember drinking with Ben one night in 2001 when he recounted his famous story of taking a bullet in the posterior during his military service in Israel, which he served shortly before joining our group,” Durkin wrote. “He described in vivid detail patrolling the front line and backtracking across war-torn countryside while gunfire peppered the ground.”

    “He was proud of his time in the military, despite our endless teasing about the wound we never asked to see,” he added.

    Durkin also said he remembered “passionately debating the finer points of the Israel-Palestine conflict with Ben, who was obviously deeply engaged with the issue.”

    On Wednesday, the Australian broadcaster quoted his uncle Willy Zygier as saying he had “no idea what is true, what isn't true.”

    “All I know is there’s a family tragedy.  Every suicide is a tragedy. That’s all I’ve got to say,” he said. “Ben’s parents are in mourning. I don’t know if they’ll talk. And I’m a humble musician. I don’t know anything.”

    Reuters contributed to this report.

    Related:

    Fatah, Hamas hold reconciliation talks ahead of possible peace talks with Israel

    UN panel's report: Israel must withdraw all settlers from West Bank

    Rights group: Israel using deadly force against unarmed protesters

    119 comments

    More Israeli terrorism...

    Show more
    Explore related topics: israel, australia, allen, featured, alon, prisoner-x, ben-zygier

Browse

  • featured,
  • world-news,
  • syria,
  • china,
  • europe,
  • afghanistan,
  • world,
  • middle-east,
  • israel,
  • updated,
  • iran,
  • pakistan,
  • egypt,
  • russia,
  • uk,
  • north-korea,
  • london,
  • africa,
  • military,
  • assad,
  • protest,
  • france,
  • environment,
  • al-qaida,
  • taliban,
  • britain,
  • nuclear,
  • italy,
  • india,
  • terrorism,
  • germany,
  • asia,
  • japan,
  • vatican,
  • south-africa,
  • mexico,
  • economy,
  • turkey,
  • human-rights,
  • crime,
  • pope
Also
Advertise | AdChoices

Archives

  • 2013
    • June (190)
    • May (258)
    • April (275)
    • March (432)
    • February (332)
    • January (323)
  • 2012
    • December (332)
    • November (332)
    • October (313)
    • September (360)
    • August (362)
    • July (310)
    • June (351)
    • May (427)
    • April (404)
    • March (427)
    • February (347)
    • January (284)
  • 2011
    • December (357)
    • November (3)

Most Commented

  • US offers Syrian rebels 'military support,' alleges Assad used chemical weapons (1745)
  • 98-year-old charged with 'unlawful execution, torture' of Jews during World War II (1005)
  • Kerry calls Afghanistan's Karzai to ease anger over Taliban office (784)
  • Obama announces extra $300 million in aid for Syrians, refugees (701)
  • Obama and Putin cite differences on Syria but say they want violence to end (787)
  • US, Taliban to meet in Qatar for 'key milestone' toward ending Afghanistan war (735)
  • US military officials say help for Syria likely to escalate gradually (360)

Other blogs

  • Cosmic Log
  • Red Tape Chronicles
  • PhotoBlog
  • US News
  • Open Channel

NBCNews.com top stories

3147,10
© 2013 NBCNews.com
  • World news on NBCNews.com
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Site map
  • Careers
  • Closed captioning
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertise